Data Sources and Methodology for the Research.com Best Earth Science Universities in Canada Ranking (4th Edition)
The 4th edition of the Research.com Best Earth Science Universities in Canada Ranking is founded on data collected from leading bibliometric databases, with primary sources being OpenAlex and CrossRef, complemented by multiple other reputable data sources. The bibliometric data underpinning the citation-based metrics used in this ranking were collected as of November 27, 2024.
Institutions' positions in the ranking are determined by the aggregate of D-indexes (Discipline H-index) of all affiliated scholars whose primary area of publication is Earth Science. It is critical to note that the D-index only includes data on publications and citations specific to the Earth Science discipline, ensuring a focused and discipline-relevant evaluation.
Scope of the Evaluated Research
For this edition, a detailed assessment was conducted on 279,971 scientist profiles identified through various bibliometric data channels. From this pool, 31,170 researchers specializing in Earth Science were subject to in-depth analysis. Each scientist considered for the ranking had to meet a qualifying D-index threshold of 30, with the majority of their major publications situated firmly within the Earth Science domain.
Further, the evaluation protocol integrates qualitative measures such as a scientist’s awards and achievements in Earth Science. The D-index threshold used to filter top researchers is set in increments of 10, tailored to the total pool of scholars estimated for each discipline. This approach guarantees inclusion of at least the top 1% of leading scholars in every field. An additional criterion requires that there is at most a 30% difference between a scientist’s general H-index and their D-index to ensure genuine disciplinary expertise. The selection process doubly weighs significant recognitions and field-specific accomplishments of each candidate.
Additional Verification Practices
The researchers developing this ranking maintain a clear understanding that raw bibliometric data are not to be viewed as absolute measures of scholarly output. Accordingly, each scientist profile underwent thorough manual verification and was cross-validated against publications from a spectrum of trusted sources.
While the number of papers published in high-tier journals and conference proceedings does not contribute directly to a researcher’s rank within Research.com, it is acknowledged as an informative secondary indicator of influence and research contribution. The ultimate position in the ranking stems from each scientist’s H-index, with data meticulously extracted from OpenAlex and CrossRef—undoubtedly the most reliable bibliometric platforms available for academic research assessment.
Comprehensive details about the methodology can be accessed via our methodology page.
Research.com Agenda
At Research.com, our mission is to motivate scientists, industry leaders, and policymakers globally to track the directions in which top experts are advancing. We strive to provide clear, evidence-based insight for the entire research community—enabling identification of leading specialists within diverse disciplines, across various countries, and within individual research institutions.
Key Results of the 4th Edition Ranking
-
Top 3 Canadian universities by number of leading Earth Science scholars:
- University of Alberta — 41 scientists
- University of British Columbia — 32 scientists
- Dalhousie University — 22 scientists
-
Global representation of the most prominent Earth Science scholars: Brown University, KU Leuven, Macquarie University, Curtin University, Utrecht University, University of Colorado Boulder, University of Hong Kong, China University of Geosciences, Xi'an Jiaotong University, and University of Bristol.
-
Top Earth Science Scientists Worldwide:
-
Professor James W. Head (Brown University) — D-index of 148 (Ranked #1 globally)
-
Jean Poesen (KU Leuven) — D-index of 147 (Ranked #2 globally)
-
William L. Griffin (Macquarie University) — D-index of 144 (Ranked #3 globally)
-
Statistical benchmarks for the top-tier institutions:
-
The average total D-index for the top 5% universities: 2404 (compared to an average of 377 for all 822 included institutions)
-
The average number of published articles in Earth Science for the top 5% of scholars: 9,544 (compared to an average of 1,521 for all institutions)
-
The average number of citations for researchers in the top 1% universities: 279,971 (against an average of 80,226 for all institutions)
These results underscore the rigorous, transparent, and data-driven approach that defines the Research.com ranking, offering valuable insights to the scientific and academic community.