World's Best Scientists 2026 revealed!
VIEW LIST
Robert W. Taft

D-Index & Metrics

Discipline name D-Index World Ranking National Ranking Publications Citations
Chemistry 86 2477 867 370 44943

Robert W. Taft publications per year

The chart shows the history of publications by Robert W. Taft between 1950 and 2011, highlighting the no. of papers published in each year and offering an overview of the publication velocity of this scholar. Robert W. Taft published across 62 years, from 1950 to 2011, averaging 5.7 papers a year. Output peaked at 23 publications in 1987. 2 of the 354 publications appeared in the last two years.

No. of publications
5 10 15 20
Bar chart. Horizontal axis: year, 1950 to 2011. Vertical axis: number of publications, 0 to 23. Peak 23 publications in 1987. 1950: 4 publications 1951: 4 publications 1952: 5 publications 1953: 5 publications 1954: 4 publications 1955: 7 publications 1956: 3 publications 1957: 9 publications 1958: 2 publications 1959: 7 publications 1960: 5 publications 1961: 4 publications 1962: 3 publications 1963: 3 publications 1964: 3 publications 1965: 6 publications 1966: 4 publications 1967: 6 publications 1968: 4 publications 1969: 3 publications 1970: 2 publications 1971: 3 publications 1972: 11 publications 1973: 5 publications 1974: 4 publications 1975: 8 publications 1976: 13 publications 1977: 17 publications 1978: 3 publications 1979: 11 publications 1980: 9 publications 1981: 15 publications 1982: 10 publications 1983: 6 publications 1984: 12 publications 1985: 12 publications 1986: 18 publications 1987: 23 publications 1988: 23 publications 1989: 5 publications 1990: 12 publications 1991: 7 publications 1992: 2 publications 1993: 4 publications 1994: 3 publications 1995: 2 publications 1996: 6 publications 1997: 2 publications 1998: 3 publications 1999: 1 publication 2000: 3 publications 2001: 0 publications 2002: 0 publications 2003: 0 publications 2004: 0 publications 2005: 0 publications 2006: 0 publications 2007: 6 publications 2008: 0 publications 2009: 0 publications 2010: 1 publication 2011: 1 publication
1950 2011

354 publications in total across all disciplines

View publications per year as a table
Robert W. Taft: publications per year, 1950 to 2011
Year Publications
1950 4
1951 4
1952 5
1953 5
1954 4
1955 7
1956 3
1957 9
1958 2
1959 7
1960 5
1961 4
1962 3
1963 3
1964 3
1965 6
1966 4
1967 6
1968 4
1969 3
1970 2
1971 3
1972 11
1973 5
1974 4
1975 8
1976 13
1977 17
1978 3
1979 11
1980 9
1981 15
1982 10
1983 6
1984 12
1985 12
1986 18
1987 23
1988 23
1989 5
1990 12
1991 7
1992 2
1993 4
1994 3
1995 2
1996 6
1997 2
1998 3
1999 1
2000 3
2001 0
2002 0
2003 0
2004 0
2005 0
2006 0
2007 6
2008 0
2009 0
2010 1
2011 1
Total 354
Download as CSV

Robert W. Taft publication distribution in Chemistry in 2026

The chart shows the distribution of publications by all Research.com ranked scientists in the field of Chemistry in 2026. The highlighted bar marks where Robert W. Taft sits on this spectrum.

No. of scientists
250 500 750 1,000 1,250
Bar chart with 63 bars. Horizontal axis: publications, 61–80 to 1,295+. Vertical axis: number of scientists, 0 to 1,350. Most scientists, 1,350, have 161–180 publications. The last bar groups every scientist with 1,295 publications or more. The highlighted bar, 361–380 publications, is where this scientist sits. 61–80 publications: 66 scientists 81–100 publications: 302 scientists 101–120 publications: 623 scientists 121–140 publications: 918 scientists 141–160 publications: 1,218 scientists 161–180 publications: 1,350 scientists 181–200 publications: 1,344 scientists 201–220 publications: 1,281 scientists 221–240 publications: 1,216 scientists 241–260 publications: 1,100 scientists 261–280 publications: 979 scientists 281–300 publications: 939 scientists 301–320 publications: 764 scientists 321–340 publications: 643 scientists 341–360 publications: 628 scientists 361–380 publications: 522 scientists 381–400 publications: 459 scientists 401–420 publications: 397 scientists 421–440 publications: 327 scientists 441–460 publications: 270 scientists 461–480 publications: 265 scientists 481–500 publications: 252 scientists 501–520 publications: 201 scientists 521–540 publications: 185 scientists 541–560 publications: 148 scientists 561–580 publications: 148 scientists 581–600 publications: 132 scientists 601–620 publications: 114 scientists 621–640 publications: 104 scientists 641–660 publications: 91 scientists 661–680 publications: 92 scientists 681–700 publications: 73 scientists 701–720 publications: 57 scientists 721–740 publications: 54 scientists 741–760 publications: 67 scientists 761–780 publications: 45 scientists 781–800 publications: 46 scientists 801–820 publications: 39 scientists 821–840 publications: 32 scientists 841–860 publications: 36 scientists 861–880 publications: 29 scientists 881–900 publications: 26 scientists 901–920 publications: 24 scientists 921–940 publications: 14 scientists 941–960 publications: 23 scientists 961–980 publications: 28 scientists 981–1,000 publications: 15 scientists 1,001–1,020 publications: 29 scientists 1,021–1,040 publications: 12 scientists 1,041–1,060 publications: 19 scientists 1,061–1,080 publications: 12 scientists 1,081–1,100 publications: 6 scientists 1,101–1,120 publications: 8 scientists 1,121–1,140 publications: 12 scientists 1,141–1,160 publications: 5 scientists 1,161–1,180 publications: 6 scientists 1,181–1,200 publications: 14 scientists 1,201–1,220 publications: 7 scientists 1,221–1,240 publications: 2 scientists 1,241–1,260 publications: 6 scientists 1,261–1,280 publications: 4 scientists 1,281–1,294 publications: 6 scientists 1,295+ publications: 100 scientists
61–80 publications 1,295+

This scientist: 370 publications — 76th percentile

76% of scientists in this discipline score the same or lower.

The last bar groups every scientist with 1,295 publications or more.

View publications distribution as a table
Number of Chemistry scientists by publication count, Research.com 2026 ranking edition. Based on 17,934 ranked scientists.
Publications Scientists This scientist
61–80 66
81–100 302
101–120 623
121–140 918
141–160 1,218
161–180 1,350
181–200 1,344
201–220 1,281
221–240 1,216
241–260 1,100
261–280 979
281–300 939
301–320 764
321–340 643
341–360 628
361–380 522 370
381–400 459
401–420 397
421–440 327
441–460 270
461–480 265
481–500 252
501–520 201
521–540 185
541–560 148
561–580 148
581–600 132
601–620 114
621–640 104
641–660 91
661–680 92
681–700 73
701–720 57
721–740 54
741–760 67
761–780 45
781–800 46
801–820 39
821–840 32
841–860 36
861–880 29
881–900 26
901–920 24
921–940 14
941–960 23
961–980 28
981–1,000 15
1,001–1,020 29
1,021–1,040 12
1,041–1,060 19
1,061–1,080 12
1,081–1,100 6
1,101–1,120 8
1,121–1,140 12
1,141–1,160 5
1,161–1,180 6
1,181–1,200 14
1,201–1,220 7
1,221–1,240 2
1,241–1,260 6
1,261–1,280 4
1,281–1,294 6
1,295+ 100
Download as CSV

Robert W. Taft D-index placement in Chemistry in 2026

The chart shows the D-index (discipline H-index) distribution of Chemistry scientists ranked by Research.com in 2026. The highlighted bar marks where Robert W. Taft sits on this spectrum.

No. of scientists
250 500 750 1,000
Bar chart with 61 bars. Horizontal axis: D-Index, 40–41 to 159+. Vertical axis: number of scientists, 0 to 1,051. Most scientists, 1,051, have 56–57 D-Index. The last bar groups every scientist with 159 D-Index or more. The highlighted bar, 86–87 D-Index, is where this scientist sits. 40–41 D-Index: 289 scientists 42–43 D-Index: 612 scientists 44–45 D-Index: 808 scientists 46–47 D-Index: 776 scientists 48–49 D-Index: 835 scientists 50–51 D-Index: 861 scientists 52–53 D-Index: 872 scientists 54–55 D-Index: 933 scientists 56–57 D-Index: 1,051 scientists 58–59 D-Index: 930 scientists 60–61 D-Index: 882 scientists 62–63 D-Index: 834 scientists 64–65 D-Index: 731 scientists 66–67 D-Index: 775 scientists 68–69 D-Index: 683 scientists 70–71 D-Index: 646 scientists 72–73 D-Index: 561 scientists 74–75 D-Index: 501 scientists 76–77 D-Index: 437 scientists 78–79 D-Index: 388 scientists 80–81 D-Index: 354 scientists 82–83 D-Index: 292 scientists 84–85 D-Index: 275 scientists 86–87 D-Index: 254 scientists 88–89 D-Index: 235 scientists 90–91 D-Index: 185 scientists 92–93 D-Index: 192 scientists 94–95 D-Index: 155 scientists 96–97 D-Index: 163 scientists 98–99 D-Index: 125 scientists 100–101 D-Index: 105 scientists 102–103 D-Index: 105 scientists 104–105 D-Index: 112 scientists 106–107 D-Index: 88 scientists 108–109 D-Index: 68 scientists 110–111 D-Index: 69 scientists 112–113 D-Index: 65 scientists 114–115 D-Index: 79 scientists 116–117 D-Index: 61 scientists 118–119 D-Index: 44 scientists 120–121 D-Index: 37 scientists 122–123 D-Index: 40 scientists 124–125 D-Index: 33 scientists 126–127 D-Index: 26 scientists 128–129 D-Index: 34 scientists 130–131 D-Index: 35 scientists 132–133 D-Index: 25 scientists 134–135 D-Index: 27 scientists 136–137 D-Index: 17 scientists 138–139 D-Index: 16 scientists 140–141 D-Index: 20 scientists 142–143 D-Index: 20 scientists 144–145 D-Index: 15 scientists 146–147 D-Index: 9 scientists 148–149 D-Index: 9 scientists 150–151 D-Index: 16 scientists 152–153 D-Index: 11 scientists 154–155 D-Index: 9 scientists 156–157 D-Index: 3 scientists 158 D-Index: 3 scientists 159+ D-Index: 98 scientists
40–41 D-Index 159+

This scientist: 86 D-Index — 86th percentile

86% of scientists in this discipline score the same or lower.

The last bar groups every scientist with 159 D-Index or more.

View D-Index distribution as a table
Number of Chemistry scientists by D-index, Research.com 2026 ranking edition. Based on 17,934 ranked scientists.
D-Index Scientists This scientist
40–41 289
42–43 612
44–45 808
46–47 776
48–49 835
50–51 861
52–53 872
54–55 933
56–57 1,051
58–59 930
60–61 882
62–63 834
64–65 731
66–67 775
68–69 683
70–71 646
72–73 561
74–75 501
76–77 437
78–79 388
80–81 354
82–83 292
84–85 275
86–87 254 86
88–89 235
90–91 185
92–93 192
94–95 155
96–97 163
98–99 125
100–101 105
102–103 105
104–105 112
106–107 88
108–109 68
110–111 69
112–113 65
114–115 79
116–117 61
118–119 44
120–121 37
122–123 40
124–125 33
126–127 26
128–129 34
130–131 35
132–133 25
134–135 27
136–137 17
138–139 16
140–141 20
142–143 20
144–145 15
146–147 9
148–149 9
150–151 16
152–153 11
154–155 9
156–157 3
158 3
159+ 98
Download as CSV

Research.com Recognitions

  • 1956 - Fellow of Alfred P. Sloan Foundation

Overview

Robert W. Taft was affiliated with the University of California, Irvine, in the United States. Their career spanned various research efforts, during which they contributed to the academic community primarily through their affiliation with this institution.

Robert W. Taft was recognized in 1956 as a Fellow of the Alfred P. Sloan Foundation, an acknowledgment that denotes a significant professional distinction during their active years.

Data related to specific research papers, coauthors, publication venues, fields of study, subfields, and main topics of work was not available. Therefore, details such as published titles, research collaborations, and thematic focus areas cannot be outlined.

Best Publications

  • Linear solvation energy relationships. 23. A comprehensive collection of the solvatochromic parameters, .pi.*, .alpha., and .beta., and some methods for simplifying the generalized solvatochromic equation

    Mortimer J. Kamlet;Jose Luis M. Abboud;Michael H. Abraham;R. W. Taft

  • The solvatochromic comparison method. I. The .beta.-scale of solvent hydrogen-bond acceptor (HBA) basicities

    Unknown

  • The solvatochromic comparison method. 6. The .pi.* scale of solvent polarities

    Unknown

  • The solvatochromic comparison method. 2. The .alpha.-scale of solvent hydrogen-bond donor (HBD) acidities

    Unknown

  • Linear solvation energy relations

    Robert W. Taft;Jose-Luis M. Abboud;Mortimer J. Kamlet;Michael H. Abraham

  • Linear solvation energy relationship. 46. An improved equation for correlation and prediction of octanol/water partition coefficients of organic nonelectrolytes (including strong hydrogen bond donor solutes)

    Mortimer J. Kamlet;Ruth M. Doherty;Michael H. Abraham;Yizhak Marcus

  • Polar and Steric Substituent Constants for Aliphatic and o-Benzoate Groups from Rates of Esterification and Hydrolysis of Esters1

    Robert W. Taft

  • The Gas-Phase Acidities of Very Strong Neutral Bronsted Acids

    Ilmar A. Koppel;Robert W. Taft;Frederick Anvia;Shi-Zheng Zhu

  • Structural and solvent effects evaluated from acidities measured in dimethyl sulfoxide and in the gas phase

    Robert W. Taft;Frederick G. Bordwell

  • The General Nature of the Proportionality of Polar Effects of Substituent Groups in Organic Chemistry

    Robert W. Taft

  • SIGMA VALUES FROM REACTIVITIES1

    Robert W. Taft

  • Fluorine Nuclear Magnetic Resonance Shielding in meta-Substituted Fluorobenzenes. The Effect of Solvent on the Inductive Order

    Robert W. Taft;Elton Price

  • Linear Free Energy Relationships from Rates of Esterification and Hydrolysis of Aliphatic and Ortho-substituted Benzoate Esters

    Robert W. Taft

  • The General Applicability of a Fixed Scale of Inductive Effects. II. Inductive Effects of Dipolar Substituents in the Reactivities of m- and p-Substituted Derivatives of Benzene1,2

    Robert W. Taft;Irwin C. Lewis

  • Fluorine Nuclear Magnetic Resonance Shielding in p-Substituted Fluorobenzenes. The Influence of Structure and Solvent on Resonance Effects

    Robert W. Taft;Elton. Price;Irwin R. Fox;Irwin C. Lewis

  • Linear Solvation Energy Relationships: 36. Molecular Properties Governing Solubilities of Organic Nonelectrolytes In Water

    Mortimer J. Kamlet;Ruth M. Doherty;Jose-Luis M. Abboud;Michael H. Abraham

  • Linear Solvation Energy Relationships. Standard Molar Gibbs Free Energies and Enthalpies of Transfer of Ions from Water into Nonaqueous Solvents

    Y. Marcus;M. J. Kamlet;R. W. Taft

  • Studies of hydrogen-bonded complex formation with p-fluorophenol. V. Linear free energy relationships with OH reference acids

    Robert W. Taft;D. Gurka;Louis Joris;Paul von R. Schleyer

  • A scale of directional substituent polarizability parameters from ab initio calculations of polarizability potentials

    Warren J. Hehre;Chin Fong. Pau;Allan D. Headley;Robert W. Taft

  • Gas phase basicities and relative proton affinities of compounds between water and ammonia from pulsed ion cyclotron resonance thermal equilibriums measurements

    J. F. Wolf;R. H. Staley;I. Koppel;M. Taagepera

  • Study of retention processes in reversed-phase high-performance liquid chromatography by the use of the solvatochromic comparison method.

    Paul C. Sadek;Peter W. Carr;Ruth M. Doherty;Mortimer J. Kamlet

  • Solvent effects in organic chemistry: recent developments

    M. H. Abraham;P. L. Grellier;J.-L. M. Abboud;R. M. Doherty

  • The Nature and Analysis of Substitutent Electronic Effects

    Robert W. Taft;R. D. Topsom

Frequent Co-Authors

Michael H. Abraham
Michael H. Abraham University College London
Warren J. Hehre
Warren J. Hehre University of California, Irvine
Mortimer J. Kamlet
Mortimer J. Kamlet Silver Spring Networks
Javier Catalán
Javier Catalán Autonomous University of Madrid
José Elguero
José Elguero Spanish National Research Council
Ruth M. Doherty
Ruth M. Doherty University of Edinburgh
Rosa M. Claramunt
Rosa M. Claramunt National University of Distance Education
William F. Reynolds
William F. Reynolds University of Toronto
Lionel Goodman
Lionel Goodman Rutgers, The State University of New Jersey
Manuel Yáñez
Manuel Yáñez Autonomous University of Madrid

If you think any of the details on this page are incorrect, let us know.

Report an issue

We appreciate your kind effort to assist us to improve this page, it would be helpful providing us with as much detail as possible in the text box below:

Related Online Degrees & Career Pathways

Studying Chemistry in the USA opens doors to various specialized career paths, many of which can be pursued through related online degrees. For those interested in healthcare, becoming a pharmacist is a rewarding option. Understanding the pharmacist salary and required qualifications can help students plan their educational journey effectively.

For individuals drawn to the forensic side of chemistry, programs like a forensic science degree online offer flexible ways to gain essential skills. This degree often leads to roles in criminal investigation and laboratory analysis, fields that highly value chemical expertise.

Another intriguing career is that of an autopsy technician, a role that combines anatomy and chemistry. Exploring the autopsy technician salary and job outlook can provide insight into this specialized profession.

For those interested in the psychological aspects linked to criminal investigations, pursuing a masters in forensic psychology online offers advanced training with flexible scheduling, enhancing career prospects in forensic settings.

Best Scientists Citing Robert W. Taft

Michael H. Abraham

Michael H. Abraham

University College London

Publications: 99

William E. Acree

William E. Acree

University of North Texas

Publications: 46

Tadeusz M. Krygowski

Tadeusz M. Krygowski

University of Warsaw

Publications: 43

Ivo Leito

Ivo Leito

University of Tartu

Publications: 41

Manuel Yáñez

Manuel Yáñez

Autonomous University of Madrid

Publications: 39

José Elguero

José Elguero

Spanish National Research Council

Publications: 38

Otilia Mó

Otilia Mó

Autonomous University of Madrid

Publications: 33

Javier Catalán

Javier Catalán

Autonomous University of Madrid

Publications: 33

Alan R. Katritzky

Alan R. Katritzky

University of Florida

Publications: 30

Ibon Alkorta

Ibon Alkorta

Spanish National Research Council

Publications: 29

Liansheng Wang

Liansheng Wang

Nanjing University

Publications: 25

Peter W. Carr

Peter W. Carr

University of Minnesota

Publications: 24

Yizhak Marcus

Yizhak Marcus

Hebrew University of Jerusalem

Publications: 20

Pierre-Alain Carrupt

Pierre-Alain Carrupt

École Polytechnique Fédérale de Lausanne

Publications: 20

Bernard Testa

Bernard Testa

University of Lausanne

Publications: 17

Omar A. El Seoud

Omar A. El Seoud

Universidade de São Paulo

Publications: 16

Related Chemistry Rankings & Guides

2027 How to Become a Medical Examiner: Education, Salary, and Job Outlook

2027 How to Become a Medical Examiner: Education, Salary, and Job Outlook
2027 How to Become a Coroner: Education, Salary, and Job Outlook

2027 How to Become a Coroner: Education, Salary, and Job Outlook
2027 Fastest Online Forensic Science Degree Programs You Can Finish in Under 2 Years

2027 Fastest Online Forensic Science Degree Programs You Can Finish in Under 2 Years
2027 Forensic Science Degree Coursework Explained: What Classes Can You Expect to Take?

2027 Forensic Science Degree Coursework Explained: What Classes Can You Expect to Take?
2027 How to Become a Crime Scene Photographer: Education, Salary, and Job Outlook

2027 How to Become a Crime Scene Photographer: Education, Salary, and Job Outlook
2027 How Much Does a Forensic Science Degree Program Cost? Tuition, Fees & Total Expense Breakdown

2027 How Much Does a Forensic Science Degree Program Cost? Tuition, Fees & Total Expense Breakdown
2027 How Fast Can You Get a Chemistry Degree Online?

2027 How Fast Can You Get a Chemistry Degree Online?
2027 Biotechnology Careers: Guide to Career Paths, Options & Salary

2027 Biotechnology Careers: Guide to Career Paths, Options & Salary
2027 How Fast Can You Get a Forensic Science Degree Online?

2027 How Fast Can You Get a Forensic Science Degree Online?
2027 Is Demand for Forensic Science Degree Graduates Growing or Declining?

2027 Is Demand for Forensic Science Degree Graduates Growing or Declining?
2027 How to Become a Medicolegal Death Investigator: Education, Salary, and Job Outlook

2027 How to Become a Medicolegal Death Investigator: Education, Salary, and Job Outlook
2027 Online Chemistry Degree Programs Costs: Tuition & Fees

2027 Online Chemistry Degree Programs Costs: Tuition & Fees
2027 Can You Get a Forensic Science Degree Master's Without a Related Bachelor's Degree?

2027 Can You Get a Forensic Science Degree Master's Without a Related Bachelor's Degree?
2027 Credit Requirements for a Forensic Science Degree Explained

2027 Credit Requirements for a Forensic Science Degree Explained

Recently Published Articles

2027 Best Online Nurse Practitioner Programs for Telehealth Careers

2027 Best Online Nurse Practitioner Programs for Telehealth Careers
2027 Best Online Real Estate Bachelor’s Programs

2027 Best Online Real Estate Bachelor’s Programs
2027 How Much Does a Teaching Degree Program Cost? Tuition, Fees & Total Expense Breakdown

2027 How Much Does a Teaching Degree Program Cost? Tuition, Fees & Total Expense Breakdown
2027 How to Become a Police Officer: Education Requirements in Indiana

2027 How to Become a Police Officer: Education Requirements in Indiana
2027 Christian Ministry Degree Careers Ranked by Salary, Growth, and Work-Life Balance

2027 Christian Ministry Degree Careers Ranked by Salary, Growth, and Work-Life Balance
2027 Easiest Online Degrees

2027 Easiest Online Degrees
2027 Which Nonprofit Management Degree Careers Offer the Best Return Without Graduate School?

2027 Which Nonprofit Management Degree Careers Offer the Best Return Without Graduate School?
2027 Best Online Master’s in Curriculum and Instruction Programs

2027 Best Online Master’s in Curriculum and Instruction Programs
2027 Cheapest Online Hospitality Management & Tourism Bachelor's Degrees That Pay Well: Tuition, Duration, and Earnings

2027 Cheapest Online Hospitality Management & Tourism Bachelor's Degrees That Pay Well: Tuition, Duration, and Earnings
2027 Easiest Communications Degree Programs

2027 Easiest Communications Degree Programs
2027 Self-Paced Online General Psychology Bachelor's Degree Programs

2027 Self-Paced Online General Psychology Bachelor's Degree Programs
2027 Are There Any One-Year Online Applied Behavior Analysis Degree Programs Worth Considering?

2027 Are There Any One-Year Online Applied Behavior Analysis Degree Programs Worth Considering?
2027 Remote Jobs You Can Get With a Fashion Merchandising Master's Degree

2027 Remote Jobs You Can Get With a Fashion Merchandising Master's Degree
2027 Entry-Level Jobs With a Gerontology Degree

2027 Entry-Level Jobs With a Gerontology Degree
2027 Special Education Master's Degree vs Graduate Certificate: Which Is Better?

2027 Special Education Master's Degree vs Graduate Certificate: Which Is Better?
2027 Most Popular Concentrations in Clinical Psychology Degrees

2027 Most Popular Concentrations in Clinical Psychology Degrees
2027 Online Data Analytics Degrees With SQL Coursework

2027 Online Data Analytics Degrees With SQL Coursework
2027 Accelerated Online Public Administration Degree Programs VS Weekly Start Online Degrees: Which Is Faster

2027 Accelerated Online Public Administration Degree Programs VS Weekly Start Online Degrees: Which Is Faster
2027 Healthcare Administration Careers: Guide to Career Paths, Options & Salary

2027 Healthcare Administration Careers: Guide to Career Paths, Options & Salary
2027 CIA Agent Qualifications and Job Requirements

2027 CIA Agent Qualifications and Job Requirements
2027 Are There Any One-Year Online Forensic Psychology Degree Programs Worth Considering?

2027 Are There Any One-Year Online Forensic Psychology Degree Programs Worth Considering?