World's Best Scientists 2026 revealed!
VIEW LIST
Clive Tadhunter

D-Index & Metrics

Discipline name D-Index World Ranking Current World Ranking National Ranking Current National Ranking Publications Citations
Physics 74 3490 3316 306 294 392 15952

Clive Tadhunter publications per year

The chart shows the history of publications by Clive Tadhunter between 1984 and 2025, highlighting the no. of papers published in each year and offering an overview of the publication velocity of this scholar. Clive Tadhunter published across 42 years, from 1984 to 2025, averaging 9.8 papers a year. Output peaked at 24 publications in 2003. 14 of the 410 publications appeared in the last two years.

No. of publications
5 10 15 20
Bar chart. Horizontal axis: year, 1984 to 2025. Vertical axis: number of publications, 0 to 24. Peak 24 publications in 2003. 1984: 1 publication 1985: 0 publications 1986: 1 publication 1987: 2 publications 1988: 3 publications 1989: 12 publications 1990: 7 publications 1991: 9 publications 1992: 4 publications 1993: 8 publications 1994: 14 publications 1995: 6 publications 1996: 13 publications 1997: 7 publications 1998: 8 publications 1999: 8 publications 2000: 7 publications 2001: 9 publications 2002: 11 publications 2003: 24 publications 2004: 8 publications 2005: 21 publications 2006: 11 publications 2007: 20 publications 2008: 16 publications 2009: 17 publications 2010: 16 publications 2011: 17 publications 2012: 12 publications 2013: 8 publications 2014: 14 publications 2015: 10 publications 2016: 14 publications 2017: 10 publications 2018: 7 publications 2019: 8 publications 2020: 3 publications 2021: 13 publications 2022: 5 publications 2023: 12 publications 2024: 10 publications 2025: 4 publications
1984 2025

410 publications in total across all disciplines

View publications per year as a table
Clive Tadhunter: publications per year, 1984 to 2025
Year Publications
1984 1
1985 0
1986 1
1987 2
1988 3
1989 12
1990 7
1991 9
1992 4
1993 8
1994 14
1995 6
1996 13
1997 7
1998 8
1999 8
2000 7
2001 9
2002 11
2003 24
2004 8
2005 21
2006 11
2007 20
2008 16
2009 17
2010 16
2011 17
2012 12
2013 8
2014 14
2015 10
2016 14
2017 10
2018 7
2019 8
2020 3
2021 13
2022 5
2023 12
2024 10
2025 4
Total 410
Download as CSV

Clive Tadhunter publication distribution in Physics in 2026

The chart shows the distribution of publications by all Research.com ranked scientists in the field of Physics in 2026. The highlighted bar marks where Clive Tadhunter sits on this spectrum.

No. of scientists
50 100 150
Bar chart with 70 bars. Horizontal axis: publications, 103–122 to 1,469+. Vertical axis: number of scientists, 0 to 162. Most scientists, 162, have 323–342 publications. The last bar groups every scientist with 1,469 publications or more. The highlighted bar, 383–402 publications, is where this scientist sits. 103–122 publications: 7 scientists 123–142 publications: 10 scientists 143–162 publications: 31 scientists 163–182 publications: 35 scientists 183–202 publications: 53 scientists 203–222 publications: 81 scientists 223–242 publications: 85 scientists 243–262 publications: 112 scientists 263–282 publications: 114 scientists 283–302 publications: 126 scientists 303–322 publications: 136 scientists 323–342 publications: 162 scientists 343–362 publications: 155 scientists 363–382 publications: 156 scientists 383–402 publications: 134 scientists 403–422 publications: 145 scientists 423–442 publications: 147 scientists 443–462 publications: 131 scientists 463–482 publications: 131 scientists 483–502 publications: 116 scientists 503–522 publications: 106 scientists 523–542 publications: 103 scientists 543–562 publications: 87 scientists 563–582 publications: 84 scientists 583–602 publications: 94 scientists 603–622 publications: 70 scientists 623–642 publications: 76 scientists 643–662 publications: 60 scientists 663–682 publications: 54 scientists 683–702 publications: 60 scientists 703–722 publications: 48 scientists 723–742 publications: 64 scientists 743–762 publications: 48 scientists 763–782 publications: 37 scientists 783–802 publications: 43 scientists 803–822 publications: 34 scientists 823–842 publications: 36 scientists 843–862 publications: 32 scientists 863–882 publications: 32 scientists 883–902 publications: 31 scientists 903–922 publications: 25 scientists 923–942 publications: 15 scientists 943–962 publications: 24 scientists 963–982 publications: 13 scientists 983–1,002 publications: 21 scientists 1,003–1,022 publications: 21 scientists 1,023–1,042 publications: 16 scientists 1,043–1,062 publications: 9 scientists 1,063–1,082 publications: 19 scientists 1,083–1,102 publications: 11 scientists 1,103–1,122 publications: 17 scientists 1,123–1,142 publications: 11 scientists 1,143–1,162 publications: 7 scientists 1,163–1,182 publications: 4 scientists 1,183–1,202 publications: 10 scientists 1,203–1,222 publications: 8 scientists 1,223–1,242 publications: 16 scientists 1,243–1,262 publications: 4 scientists 1,263–1,282 publications: 10 scientists 1,283–1,302 publications: 5 scientists 1,303–1,322 publications: 7 scientists 1,323–1,342 publications: 4 scientists 1,343–1,362 publications: 8 scientists 1,363–1,382 publications: 6 scientists 1,383–1,402 publications: 7 scientists 1,403–1,422 publications: 3 scientists 1,423–1,442 publications: 4 scientists 1,443–1,462 publications: 4 scientists 1,463–1,468 publications: 3 scientists 1,469+ publications: 100 scientists
103–122 publications 1,469+

This scientist: 392 publications — 36th percentile

36% of scientists in this discipline score the same or lower.

The last bar groups every scientist with 1,469 publications or more.

View publications distribution as a table
Number of Physics scientists by publication count, Research.com 2026 ranking edition. Based on 3,678 ranked scientists.
Publications Scientists This scientist
103–122 7
123–142 10
143–162 31
163–182 35
183–202 53
203–222 81
223–242 85
243–262 112
263–282 114
283–302 126
303–322 136
323–342 162
343–362 155
363–382 156
383–402 134 392
403–422 145
423–442 147
443–462 131
463–482 131
483–502 116
503–522 106
523–542 103
543–562 87
563–582 84
583–602 94
603–622 70
623–642 76
643–662 60
663–682 54
683–702 60
703–722 48
723–742 64
743–762 48
763–782 37
783–802 43
803–822 34
823–842 36
843–862 32
863–882 32
883–902 31
903–922 25
923–942 15
943–962 24
963–982 13
983–1,002 21
1,003–1,022 21
1,023–1,042 16
1,043–1,062 9
1,063–1,082 19
1,083–1,102 11
1,103–1,122 17
1,123–1,142 11
1,143–1,162 7
1,163–1,182 4
1,183–1,202 10
1,203–1,222 8
1,223–1,242 16
1,243–1,262 4
1,263–1,282 10
1,283–1,302 5
1,303–1,322 7
1,323–1,342 4
1,343–1,362 8
1,363–1,382 6
1,383–1,402 7
1,403–1,422 3
1,423–1,442 4
1,443–1,462 4
1,463–1,468 3
1,469+ 100
Download as CSV

Clive Tadhunter D-index placement in Physics in 2026

The chart shows the D-index (discipline H-index) distribution of Physics scientists ranked by Research.com in 2026. The highlighted bar marks where Clive Tadhunter sits on this spectrum.

No. of scientists
50 100 150
Bar chart with 59 bars. Horizontal axis: D-Index, 70–71 to 185+. Vertical axis: number of scientists, 0 to 167. Most scientists, 167, have 80–81 D-Index. The last bar groups every scientist with 185 D-Index or more. The highlighted bar, 74–75 D-Index, is where this scientist sits. 70–71 D-Index: 76 scientists 72–73 D-Index: 110 scientists 74–75 D-Index: 143 scientists 76–77 D-Index: 153 scientists 78–79 D-Index: 144 scientists 80–81 D-Index: 167 scientists 82–83 D-Index: 167 scientists 84–85 D-Index: 166 scientists 86–87 D-Index: 132 scientists 88–89 D-Index: 155 scientists 90–91 D-Index: 134 scientists 92–93 D-Index: 137 scientists 94–95 D-Index: 102 scientists 96–97 D-Index: 112 scientists 98–99 D-Index: 110 scientists 100–101 D-Index: 116 scientists 102–103 D-Index: 97 scientists 104–105 D-Index: 103 scientists 106–107 D-Index: 87 scientists 108–109 D-Index: 90 scientists 110–111 D-Index: 67 scientists 112–113 D-Index: 78 scientists 114–115 D-Index: 75 scientists 116–117 D-Index: 67 scientists 118–119 D-Index: 69 scientists 120–121 D-Index: 60 scientists 122–123 D-Index: 59 scientists 124–125 D-Index: 53 scientists 126–127 D-Index: 42 scientists 128–129 D-Index: 41 scientists 130–131 D-Index: 33 scientists 132–133 D-Index: 32 scientists 134–135 D-Index: 45 scientists 136–137 D-Index: 19 scientists 138–139 D-Index: 24 scientists 140–141 D-Index: 28 scientists 142–143 D-Index: 31 scientists 144–145 D-Index: 22 scientists 146–147 D-Index: 20 scientists 148–149 D-Index: 12 scientists 150–151 D-Index: 16 scientists 152–153 D-Index: 24 scientists 154–155 D-Index: 23 scientists 156–157 D-Index: 15 scientists 158–159 D-Index: 15 scientists 160–161 D-Index: 11 scientists 162–163 D-Index: 17 scientists 164–165 D-Index: 12 scientists 166–167 D-Index: 11 scientists 168–169 D-Index: 9 scientists 170–171 D-Index: 9 scientists 172–173 D-Index: 11 scientists 174–175 D-Index: 4 scientists 176–177 D-Index: 8 scientists 178–179 D-Index: 5 scientists 180–181 D-Index: 3 scientists 182–183 D-Index: 4 scientists 184 D-Index: 4 scientists 185+ D-Index: 99 scientists
70–71 D-Index 185+

This scientist: 74 D-Index — 7th percentile

7% of scientists in this discipline score the same or lower.

The last bar groups every scientist with 185 D-Index or more.

View D-Index distribution as a table
Number of Physics scientists by D-index, Research.com 2026 ranking edition. Based on 3,678 ranked scientists.
D-Index Scientists This scientist
70–71 76
72–73 110
74–75 143 74
76–77 153
78–79 144
80–81 167
82–83 167
84–85 166
86–87 132
88–89 155
90–91 134
92–93 137
94–95 102
96–97 112
98–99 110
100–101 116
102–103 97
104–105 103
106–107 87
108–109 90
110–111 67
112–113 78
114–115 75
116–117 67
118–119 69
120–121 60
122–123 59
124–125 53
126–127 42
128–129 41
130–131 33
132–133 32
134–135 45
136–137 19
138–139 24
140–141 28
142–143 31
144–145 22
146–147 20
148–149 12
150–151 16
152–153 24
154–155 23
156–157 15
158–159 15
160–161 11
162–163 17
164–165 12
166–167 11
168–169 9
170–171 9
172–173 11
174–175 4
176–177 8
178–179 5
180–181 3
182–183 4
184 4
185+ 99
Download as CSV

Overview

Clive Tadhunter is affiliated with the University of Sheffield in the United Kingdom. Their research primarily focuses on the field of Physics and Astronomy, with a strong emphasis on Astronomy and Astrophysics as well as related subfields such as Instrumentation and Nuclear and High Energy Physics. Their work also extends into areas like Computer Vision and Pattern Recognition and Computational Mechanics.

The scientist's research topics broadly cover the formation, evolution, and phenomena of galaxies, as well as astrophysical processes and observations. Specific topics include:

  • Galaxies: Formation, Evolution, Phenomena
  • Astrophysics and Star Formation Studies
  • Astronomy and Astrophysical Research
  • Astrophysical Phenomena and Observations
  • Gamma-ray bursts and supernovae
  • Astrophysics and Cosmic Phenomena
  • Radio Astronomy Observations and Technology

Tadhunter has contributed extensively to academic journals, regularly publishing in the following venues:

  • Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society
  • Astronomy and Astrophysics
  • arXiv (Cornell University)
  • Astronomische Nachrichten
  • The Astrophysical Journal

Their recent papers illustrate a focus on quasars, active galactic nuclei (AGN), and galaxy interactions, including:

  • "The diverse cold molecular gas contents, morphologies, and kinematics of type-2 quasars as seen by ALMA" (2021) in Astronomy and Astrophysics
  • "AGN-driven outflows and the AGN feedback efficiency in young radio galaxies" (2020) in Astronomy and Astrophysics
  • "Galaxy interactions are the dominant trigger for local type 2 quasars" (2023) in Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society
  • "Taking snapshots of the jet-ISM interplay: The case of PKS 0023-26" (2021) in Astronomy and Astrophysics
  • "Multiphase characterization of AGN winds in five local type-2 quasars" (2023) in Astronomy and Astrophysics

Frequent co-authors with whom Clive Tadhunter has collaborated include:

  • R. Morganti
  • C. Ramos Almeida
  • Tom Oosterloo
  • L. R. Holden
  • P. S. Bessiere

Tadhunter's academic output reflects a sustained engagement with observational and theoretical aspects of extragalactic astrophysics, with particular attention to phenomena such as AGN feedback mechanisms and galaxy interaction processes. Their contributions extend to instrumentation techniques supporting these astrophysical explorations.

Best Publications

  • Fast outflows in compact radio sources: evidence for AGN-induced feedback in the early stages of radio source evolution

    J. Holt;C. N. Tadhunter;R. Morganti

  • Fast neutral outflows in powerful radio galaxies : a major source of feedback in massive galaxies

    Raffaella Morganti;Raffaella Morganti;CN Tadhunter;Thomas Oosterloo;Thomas Oosterloo

  • The radio structures of southern 2-Jy radio sources

    R. Morganti;N. E. B. Killeen;C. N. Tadhunter

  • AGN outflows and feedback twenty years on

    C. M. Harrison;T. Costa;C. N. Tadhunter;A. Flütsch

  • The fast molecular outflow in the Seyfert galaxy IC 5063 as seen by ALMA

    Raffaella Morganti;Tom Oosterloo;J. B. Raymond Oonk;J. B. Raymond Oonk;Wilfred Frieswijk

  • Optical spectroscopy of a complete sample of southern 2-Jy radio sources

    C. N. Tadhunter;R. Morganti;S. di Serego Alighieri;R. A. E. Fosbury

  • Anisotropic ionizing radiation in NGC5252

    Clive Tadhunter;Zlatan Tsvetanov

  • The fast molecular outflow in the Seyfert galaxy IC5063 as seen by ALMA

    Raffaella Morganti;Tom Oosterloo;J. B. R. Oonk;Wilfred Frieswijk

  • Jet acceleration of the fast molecular outflows in the Seyfert galaxy IC 5063

    C. Tadhunter;R. Morganti;R. Morganti;M. Rose;J. B. R. Oonk

  • Spectroscopy of the near-nuclear regions of Cygnus A: estimating the mass of the supermassive black hole

    Clive Tadhunter;Alessandro Marconi;David Axon;Karen Wills

  • Emission-line activity in radio galaxies⋆

    A. Robinson;L. Binette;R. A. E. Fosbury;C. N. Tadhunter

  • Radio AGN in the local universe: unification, triggering and evolution

    Clive Tadhunter

  • The co-evolution of the obscured quasar PKS 1549-79 and its host galaxy : evidence for a high accretion rate and warm outflow

    J. Holt;C. Tadhunter;R. Morganti;R. Morganti;M. Bellamy

  • Starbursts and the triggering of the activity in nearby powerful radio galaxies

    C. Tadhunter;T. G. Robinson;R. M. González Delgado;K. Wills

  • The nature of the optical–radio correlations for powerful radio galaxies

    Clive Tadhunter;Raffaella Morganti;Andrew Robinson;Robert Dickson

  • HI absorption in radio galaxies: effect of orientation or interstellar medium?

    R. Morganti;T. A. Oosterloo;C. N. Tadhunter;G. van Moorsel

  • H i absorption in radio galaxies: effect of orientation or interstellar medium?

    R. Morganti;T. A. Oosterloo;C. N. Tadhunter;G. van Moorsel

  • The nebular contribution to the extended UV continua of powerful radio galaxies

    R. Dickson;C. Tadhunter;M. Shaw;N. Clark

  • The origin of the UV excess in powerful radio galaxies: spectroscopy and polarimetry of a complete sample of intermediate‐redshift radio galaxies

    C. Tadhunter;R. Dickson;R. Morganti;T. G. Robinson

  • PKS 2250—41 and the role of jet-cloud interactions in powerful radio galaxies

    M. Villar-Martín;C. Tadhunter;R. Morganti;D. Axon

Frequent Co-Authors

Raffaella Morganti
Raffaella Morganti Netherlands Institute for Radio Astronomy
Tom Oosterloo
Tom Oosterloo Netherlands Institute for Radio Astronomy
David Axon
David Axon University of Sussex
William B. Sparks
William B. Sparks Space Telescope Science Institute
Elaine M. Sadler
Elaine M. Sadler University of Sydney
Christopher P. O'Dea
Christopher P. O'Dea University of Manitoba
Anton M. Koekemoer
Anton M. Koekemoer Space Telescope Science Institute
Stefi A. Baum
Stefi A. Baum University of Manitoba
P. T. O'Brien
P. T. O'Brien University of Leicester
George K. Miley
George K. Miley Leiden University

External Links

Personal website of Clive Tadhunter

If you think any of the details on this page are incorrect, let us know.

Report an issue

We appreciate your kind effort to assist us to improve this page, it would be helpful providing us with as much detail as possible in the text box below:

Best Scientists Citing Clive Tadhunter

Francoise Combes

Francoise Combes

Collège de France

Publications: 114

Tom Oosterloo

Tom Oosterloo

Netherlands Institute for Radio Astronomy

Publications: 112

Raffaella Morganti

Raffaella Morganti

Netherlands Institute for Radio Astronomy

Publications: 108

Christopher P. O'Dea

Christopher P. O'Dea

University of Manitoba

Publications: 98

Alessandro Marconi

Alessandro Marconi

University of Florence

Publications: 84

Martin J. Hardcastle

Martin J. Hardcastle

University of Hertfordshire

Publications: 82

Matt J. Jarvis

Matt J. Jarvis

University of Oxford

Publications: 75

Stefi A. Baum

Stefi A. Baum

University of Manitoba

Publications: 72

Luis C. Ho

Luis C. Ho

Peking University

Publications: 62

Thaisa Storchi-Bergmann

Thaisa Storchi-Bergmann

Federal University of Rio Grande do Sul

Publications: 57

Marcella Brusa

Marcella Brusa

University of Bologna

Publications: 55

Roberto Maiolino

Roberto Maiolino

University of Cambridge

Publications: 55

Michael A. Dopita

Michael A. Dopita

Australian National University

Publications: 52

Daniel Stern

Daniel Stern

California Institute of Technology

Publications: 49

Elaine M. Sadler

Elaine M. Sadler

University of Sydney

Publications: 47

Fabrizio Fiore

Fabrizio Fiore

National Institute for Astrophysics

Publications: 47

Trending Scientists

Kiran K. Sharma

Kiran K. Sharma

International Crops Research Institute for the Semi-Arid Tropics

Nicolas Barnich

Nicolas Barnich

University of Clermont Auvergne

Nico Boon

Nico Boon

Ghent University

Dieter Bilitza

Dieter Bilitza

George Mason University

Jeffrey J. Shaw

Jeffrey J. Shaw

Universidade de São Paulo

Adriana Zingone

Adriana Zingone

Stazione Zoologica Anton Dohrn

Cecilia Bucci

Cecilia Bucci

University of Salento

Frank Madeo

Frank Madeo

University of Graz

Ari Väänänen

Ari Väänänen

Finnish Institute of Occupational Health

Philippe Bourgois

Philippe Bourgois

University of California, Los Angeles

Boris Gilburd

Boris Gilburd

Sheba Medical Center

Anssi Paasi

Anssi Paasi

University of Oulu

Jonathan P. West

Jonathan P. West

University of Miami

James K. Min

James K. Min

NewYork–Presbyterian Hospital

Leonie C. Moyle

Leonie C. Moyle

Indiana University

Daniel D. Roby

Daniel D. Roby

Oregon State University

Related Physics Rankings & Guides

2027 Most Affordable Online Space Studies Degree Programs

2027 Most Affordable Online Space Studies Degree Programs
2027 How To Become a Paleontologist? Salary & Career Paths

2027 How To Become a Paleontologist? Salary & Career Paths
2027 Fastest Online Urban Planning Degree Programs You Can Finish in Under 2 Years

2027 Fastest Online Urban Planning Degree Programs You Can Finish in Under 2 Years
2027 Admission Requirements for Physics Degree Programs

2027 Admission Requirements for Physics Degree Programs
2027 Best Online Physics Degree Programs

2027 Best Online Physics Degree Programs
2027 Online Photography Degree Programs Costs: Tuition & Fees

2027 Online Photography Degree Programs Costs: Tuition & Fees
2027 Most Affordable Online Physics Degree Programs

2027 Most Affordable Online Physics Degree Programs
2027 Best Online Space Studies Degree Programs

2027 Best Online Space Studies Degree Programs
2027 Online Photography Degree Programs for Veterans: GI Bill Benefits, Costs & Top Considerations

2027 Online Photography Degree Programs for Veterans: GI Bill Benefits, Costs & Top Considerations

Recently Published Articles

2027 Nursing Informatics Degree Master's Programs Accepting Students Now

2027 Nursing Informatics Degree Master's Programs Accepting Students Now
2027 Highest-Paying Nursing Jobs After ABSN

2027 Highest-Paying Nursing Jobs After ABSN
2027 Online Literacy Education Doctorate Programs for Experienced Professionals Without Research Backgrounds

2027 Online Literacy Education Doctorate Programs for Experienced Professionals Without Research Backgrounds
2027 Online Early Childhood Education Master's Programs at Accredited U.S. Universities

2027 Online Early Childhood Education Master's Programs at Accredited U.S. Universities
2027 Different Types of Applied Business & Technology Degrees and Their Salaries

2027 Different Types of Applied Business & Technology Degrees and Their Salaries
2027 Most Affordable Online CNC Machining Trade School Programs

2027 Most Affordable Online CNC Machining Trade School Programs
2027 Best Pharmacy Degrees for Working Adults

2027 Best Pharmacy Degrees for Working Adults
2027 Return on Investment (ROI) of a Health Education Degree Program

2027 Return on Investment (ROI) of a Health Education Degree Program
2027 How Long Does It Take to Be a Teacher in Connecticut?

2027 How Long Does It Take to Be a Teacher in Connecticut?
2027 How to Become an Electrician in Hawaii

2027 How to Become an Electrician in Hawaii
2027 Online General Psychology Bachelor's Degree Programs With No SAT or ACT Requirements

2027 Online General Psychology Bachelor's Degree Programs With No SAT or ACT Requirements
2027 Different Types of Patient Safety & Quality Degrees and Their Salaries

2027 Different Types of Patient Safety & Quality Degrees and Their Salaries
2027 Can You Complete an Online Biology Degree Program While Working Full-Time?

2027 Can You Complete an Online Biology Degree Program While Working Full-Time?
2027 Online Criminal Justice Bachelor's Degree Programs That Accept Transfer Credits

2027 Online Criminal Justice Bachelor's Degree Programs That Accept Transfer Credits
2027 Is a 2-Year Radiology Technician Degree Worth It: Accelerated Bachelor's ROI & Time Trade-Offs

2027 Is a 2-Year Radiology Technician Degree Worth It: Accelerated Bachelor's ROI & Time Trade-Offs
2027 How Long Does It Take to Earn an Online Surgical Tech Degree?

2027 How Long Does It Take to Earn an Online Surgical Tech Degree?
2027 Which Employers Hire Crime Analysis Degree Graduates? Industries, Roles, and Hiring Patterns

2027 Which Employers Hire Crime Analysis Degree Graduates? Industries, Roles, and Hiring Patterns
2027 Best Online Psychiatric Mental Health Nurse Practitioner Degree Master's Programs for Working Professionals

2027 Best Online Psychiatric Mental Health Nurse Practitioner Degree Master's Programs for Working Professionals
2027 How to Become a Healthcare Risk Manager: Education, Salary, and Job Outlook

2027 How to Become a Healthcare Risk Manager: Education, Salary, and Job Outlook
2027 How to Become a BCBA in Raleigh, NC: Education Requirements & Certification

2027 How to Become a BCBA in Raleigh, NC: Education Requirements & Certification
2027 Online Sports Science Degree Programs With No Letters of Recommendation Required

2027 Online Sports Science Degree Programs With No Letters of Recommendation Required