A School District Banned Phones Bell To Bell. Two Years Of Test Scores Show What Changed

A School District Banned Phones Bell To Bell. Two Years Of Test Scores Show What Changed

Audited and Verified:

Imed Bouchrika, PhD

by Imed Bouchrika, PhD

Co-Founder and Chief Data Scientist

Share

Can taking away students' cellphones for the entire school day make a measurable difference in how they learn? As concerns about classroom distractions and smartphone use grow, more U.S. states and school districts are restricting students' access to personal devices. As of April 15, 2026, 42 U.S. jurisdictions had adopted statewide laws or policies regulating cellphone use in public schools, reflecting a growing shift toward phone-free learning environments.

In one large Florida school district, researchers tracked the effects of a bell-to-bell phone ban introduced in 2023, examining changes in student discipline, attendance and academic performance over two school years. Suspensions increased during the first year, while modest test-score gains emerged in the second. The findings suggest that limiting phone use may offer academic benefits over time, although national research indicates that the results are not universal.

Florida's Bell-to-Bell Phone Ban Went Beyond Statewide Rules

Florida's 2023 cellphone law prohibited students from using wireless communication devices during instructional time, except when expressly directed by a teacher solely for educational purposes. But one of the state's largest school districts went further. Its policy required students to keep phones silenced and stored in their backpacks or purses throughout the school day, including lunch and transitions between classes.

The policy was in effect from the beginning of the 2023–24 school year, but disciplinary enforcement began on September 4, 2023, after an initial grace period. Researchers David Figlio of the University of Rochester and Umut Özek of RAND examined student records from the year before the ban and the following two school years. They also used smartphone-activity data to compare schools in the highest and lowest thirds of pre-ban phone activity.

The chart shows that smartphone activity declined across all three grade levels after the restriction took effect. Middle schools recorded the highest pre-ban activity, at more than 60 daily visits per 100 enrolled students, falling to about 30 in the first year and 25 in the second. High-school activity dropped from more than 45 visits to around 10, while elementary-school activity declined from approximately 25 to 15. These figures suggest that the restriction substantially reduced smartphone activity during school hours, particularly in middle and high schools. 

Suspensions Increased Before Academic Improvements Appeared

The first year of the ban brought an unexpected consequence: an increase in student disciplinary incidents and suspensions. Researchers found that schools with higher pre-ban smartphone activity experienced larger increases in disciplinary outcomes than schools with lower pre-ban activity.

The estimated first-year effects included:

The researchers found no statistically significant comparable increase among White or Hispanic students.

By the second school year, the overall disciplinary effects had largely disappeared. However, the results varied by grade level. Elementary schools recorded significant reductions in disciplinary incidents and suspensions, while elevated disciplinary outcomes in middle and high schools continued, although they had begun to ease.

The researchers suggest that the initial increase may reflect an adjustment period as schools began enforcing the restrictions. The findings highlight a potential trade-off: while the ban substantially reduced smartphone activity during school hours, its first year was also associated with increased disciplinary consequences, particularly for Black students.

Test Scores Improved in the Second Year, but Not for Every Student

The academic results followed a different timeline from the disciplinary effects. Researchers found no statistically significant improvement in test scores during the first year of the ban. In the second year, however, scores rose significantly, with the strongest gains appearing among boys and students in middle and high school. The academic improvements emerged after the initial period of stricter enforcement and higher suspensions had largely passed.

Figlio and Özek compared schools with higher pre-ban smartphone activity against those with lower activity. The estimated second-year gains were positive across the student groups shown below, although the size of the estimates varied. Middle and high school students recorded the largest estimated increase by grade level, while boys had larger gains than girls.

Estimated Effects of the Florida Phone Ban on Student Test Scores (Percentile Points)

Student GroupFirst YearSecond Year
All students+0.283+0.622**
Black students-0.292+0.657
White students+1.006***+0.965***
Hispanic students+0.380+0.643**
Boys+0.373+0.819***
Girls+0.190+0.455
Elementary school+0.213+0.509
Middle and high school+0.711**+0.905**
Note: * p < 0.10; ** p < 0.05; *** p < 0.01. Estimates are difference-in-differences effects comparing high- and low-pre-ban smartphone activity schools. Test scores are nationally normed percentile points, not percentage changes.

The table shows that estimated test-score gains became more noticeable in the second year. The overall second-year estimate increased to 0.622 percentile points and was statistically significant. The largest subgroup estimates were recorded among White students (+0.965), middle and high school students (+0.905), and boys (+0.819).

Hispanic students also recorded a statistically significant gain of 0.643 percentile points. By contrast, the estimates for Black students, girls and elementary school students were positive but not statistically significant. These results suggest that the academic benefits were not uniform across student groups.

Reduced unexcused absences may help explain some of the academic gains. The researchers found statistically significant reductions in unexcused absences in both years, with particularly pronounced effects among middle and high school students. An exploratory analysis suggested that these attendance changes could account for nearly half of the estimated test-score effects in those grade levels. However, this analysis does not establish attendance as the sole explanation for the academic improvements.

National Study: Phone Bans Reduced Phone Use, but Academic Gains Remained Limited

A separate national study examined lockable phone-pouch policies using nationwide school data. Led by researchers from Stanford, Duke, the University of Michigan and the University of Pennsylvania, the study combined standardized test scores, attendance and disciplinary records, student surveys, GPS-based device activity and a national teacher survey that received nearly 108,000 responses from educators in all 50 states. Its GPS dataset covered 40,542 schools, while Yondr's administrative records identified 4,607 U.S. public schools that had purchased phone pouches.

The national findings suggest that phone restrictions can substantially reduce phone use without producing immediate academic gains. Unlike the Florida district's backpack-storage rule, the national study examined magnetically locked pouches designed to keep phones inaccessible during the school day. 

The findings showed mixed results across six areas:

What the two studies reveal about school phone bans?

The Florida and national studies agree that restricting phone access can substantially reduce smartphone use, but their academic findings differ. In Florida, researchers found a statistically significant overall test-score improvement in the second year, with particularly strong estimates among White students, boys and middle and high school students. Hispanic students also recorded statistically significant gains. In contrast, the national study found average test-score effects close to zero over three years. High schools experienced modest positive effects, particularly in mathematics, while middle schools recorded small negative effects.

Together, the findings suggest that restricting phone access can substantially reduce smartphone activity in schools, but the academic benefits are not universal. Florida's district-level study identified modest second-year test-score gains, particularly among certain student groups, while the national study found average academic effects close to zero despite substantial reductions in phone use. Differences in policy design, enforcement, student populations and research methods may help explain the contrasting results. Ultimately, reducing phone use appears more consistently achievable than improving academic performance through phone restrictions alone.

References:

Related News
Entry-Level Hiring Fell Faster Than The Rest Of The Job Market. AI Isn't The Main Reason. thumbnail
Nurses Qualify For Loan Forgiveness That Wipes Up To 85% Of Their Debt. Here Is Who Gets It thumbnail
FAFSA Changed Again For 2027. Some Families Will Get Less Aid Without Ever Knowing Why. thumbnail
Average IQ Scores Have Fallen Since 1986. Researchers Still Disagree About Why. thumbnail
Iceland Went To A Four-Day Week In 2019. Six Years Later, Here's The Verdict. thumbnail
Nurse salaries revealed: The highest-paying states could double your income in 2026 thumbnail

Newsletter & Conference Alerts

Research.com uses the information to contact you about our relevant content.
For more information, check out our privacy policy.

Newsletter confirmation

Thank you for subscribing!

Confirmation email sent. Please click the link in the email to confirm your subscription.