Choosing an exercise science career is not just a question of what sounds interesting. It is a risk decision: some paths are tied to essential healthcare services, regulated credentials, and aging-population demand, while others depend more heavily on discretionary fitness spending, local employer density, or technologies that can automate routine coaching and assessment tasks.
This guide explains which exercise science degree jobs tend to offer stronger protection against unemployment, why those paths are more stable, and what students and working professionals can do to improve their odds. It looks at specialization, licensure, graduate education, geography, industry choice, public-sector employment, and automation risk. It also keeps salary and job-security claims in perspective: no degree guarantees employment, but credential strategy and market selection can make a measurable difference. In the labor market evidence cited for this topic, licensure and certification reduce unemployment rates by up to 35% among mid-career practitioners nationally.
Key Things to Know About the Exercise Science Degree Careers With the Lowest Unemployment Risk
Careers with state licensure-such as physical therapy-show 40% lower historical unemployment and strong recession resilience, providing critical protection against market volatility for exercise science graduates.
Regions with aging populations-like the Midwest and Southeast-exhibit 15% higher ten-year demand growth, reducing unemployment risk through sustained healthcare service needs in exercise science fields.
Advanced certifications and graduate degrees cut automation vulnerability by increasing specialized clinical skills, thereby lowering long-term unemployment exposure across entry-level to senior exercise science roles.
What Makes Exercise Science Degree Jobs More or Less Resistant to Unemployment?
Exercise science jobs are more resistant to unemployment when they are connected to essential health needs, regulated scopes of practice, and employers that cannot easily replace trained workers with lower-cost labor or software. Jobs are less secure when they rely on optional consumer spending, have low barriers to entry, or involve routine tasks that can be standardized or automated.
Unemployment risk in this field usually falls into three categories. Structural unemployment happens when the market no longer needs certain tasks because of automation, reimbursement changes, or shifts in healthcare delivery. Frictional unemployment refers to short gaps between jobs, such as moving from a fitness center to a hospital-based role. Cyclical unemployment appears during recessions, when employers cut programs that are viewed as discretionary, including some wellness and recreation services.
Key factors that lower unemployment risk
Licensure and certification: Roles that require state licensure or widely recognized credentials have stronger barriers to entry. Employers cannot simply substitute unqualified workers when budgets tighten.
Healthcare connection: Jobs tied to rehabilitation, chronic disease management, cardiac care, mobility, or prevention usually have steadier demand than general fitness roles.
Employer diversity: A region with hospitals, outpatient clinics, universities, public agencies, sports organizations, and corporate wellness employers gives graduates more options if one employer freezes hiring.
Sector growth rate: Expanding areas such as preventive care, rehabilitation, wellness, and aging-related services generally create more openings and faster reemployment options.
Role replaceability: Work that requires judgment, coaching, patient communication, clinical reasoning, and individualized exercise prescription is harder to automate than routine assessment or scheduling.
Geographic fit: Urban and suburban healthcare markets often offer more employment buffers than rural areas with fewer specialized employers.
BLS data, O*NET profiles, and Lightcast labor market analytics point to the same practical conclusion: the safest exercise science careers are usually not the broadest ones. They are the roles with defined competencies, credential expectations, and employers that depend on movement, rehabilitation, prevention, and performance expertise.
Students should therefore evaluate specialization and credentials together. Clinical exercise physiology, rehabilitation, cardiac rehabilitation, athletic training, and sports performance can all be viable, but their stability depends on credential requirements, local hiring demand, and the type of employer. If your long-term plan may shift from exercise science into broader clinical leadership, you may also compare adjacent pathways such as DNP programs online, while keeping in mind that those programs serve a different professional track.
Table of contents
Which Exercise Science Career Paths Have the Lowest Historical Unemployment Rates?
The exercise science career paths with the lowest historical unemployment risk tend to share three traits: they are connected to healthcare or institutional employers, they require licensure or respected certification, and they serve populations with ongoing needs rather than short-term consumer preferences. Analysis using over a decade's data from the BLS Current Population Survey, NACE First-Destination Survey, and Federal Reserve Bank research points to especially resilient roles in rehabilitation, therapy-adjacent care, clinical exercise physiology, and performance settings with stable funding.
Career paths with stronger historical stability
Physical therapists: Demand is supported by rehabilitation needs, musculoskeletal conditions, neurological recovery, and an aging population. Licensure limits oversupply, and many roles are embedded in essential healthcare services.
Occupational therapists: These roles benefit from state licensure, demand across schools, hospitals, clinics, and community settings, and increased attention to function, independence, and behavioral health.
Exercise physiologists: Clinical exercise physiology is strengthened by chronic disease management, cardiovascular care, diabetes-related programming, and hospital or outpatient health systems.
Certified strength and conditioning specialists: The strongest stability appears in collegiate athletics, professional sports, military performance, and well-funded training environments where credentialed expertise is valued.
Cardiac rehabilitation specialists: These roles are tied to medical necessity, post-hospital recovery, cardiac event follow-up, and specialized certification expectations.
Corporate wellness coordinators: Job security varies by employer, but large organizations that integrate wellness into benefits, risk management, or employee health strategy can provide steadier roles than small fitness businesses.
Clinical exercise specialists: Professionals working with physicians, nurses, therapists, and other clinical teams often have stronger protection than those offering general wellness services alone.
Rehabilitation counselors with exercise backgrounds: Hybrid skill sets that combine counseling, functional recovery, and movement science can reduce competition and support employment across rehabilitation systems.
These paths were comparatively resilient during the 2008-2009 recession and, in many healthcare-connected roles, recovered faster after the 2020 COVID-19 disruption than fitness-only jobs. The 2022-2024 period further reinforced the advantage of roles tied to healthcare stabilization, preventive care, and rehabilitation demand.
The important distinction is not simply “exercise science versus another major.” It is which part of the exercise science labor market you enter. A graduate working in general fitness may face very different unemployment risk than a licensed or certified professional working in a hospital, rehabilitation clinic, public agency, or performance program. Those who want to combine exercise science with operations or leadership may also consider whether a healthcare administration degree supports their long-term stability goals.
How Does the Exercise Science Job Market Compare to the National Unemployment Average?
The exercise science job market can compare favorably with the national unemployment average for college-educated workers, but only for graduates who move into specialized, credentialed, or healthcare-connected roles. The national unemployment rate for college-educated workers stands at about 2.5%, while holders of exercise science degrees in specialized roles such as clinical exercise physiologists and occupational therapy assistants experience rates closer to 1.3%.
That comparison should be interpreted carefully. A low unemployment rate does not mean every graduate finds ideal work quickly. Underemployment is a real issue in exercise science. Some graduates take jobs that use only part of their training, such as general fitness, sales, recreation, or unrelated service roles, especially before earning certifications or gaining clinical experience.
What the unemployment comparison does and does not show
Measure
What it tells you
What it may hide
Unemployment rate
How many workers are actively seeking work and not employed
Whether graduates are working in roles that match their degree
Underemployment
Whether workers are in jobs below their training level
The difference between having a job and building a career path
Job search duration
How quickly graduates move into work
Whether the first job leads to advancement or credential growth
Multi-year trends
Whether a role is stable across economic cycles
Short-term local disruptions or employer-specific layoffs
Exercise science specialties can also produce volatile annual data because some occupational groups are small. A modest change in hiring can make one year look unusually strong or weak. Multi-year averages, regional job postings, employer concentration, and credential requirements offer a more reliable picture than a single annual unemployment figure.
For graduates, the main lesson is strategic: the degree is a foundation, not a job guarantee. Lower unemployment risk usually comes from pairing the degree with clinical exposure, certification, licensure where applicable, and a labor market that has enough employers to absorb workers during downturns.
: "One exercise science graduate described the early job search as “less about finding any job and more about proving that my skills matched the role.” He faced rejections and periods without steady work, but additional certification and persistence helped him move into a position aligned with his training."
What Exercise Science Specializations Are Most In-Demand Among Employers Right Now?
The most in-demand exercise science specializations are those that solve urgent employer problems: chronic disease management, injury prevention, rehabilitation, workplace health, performance optimization, and data-informed coaching. Lightcast job postings, LinkedIn Talent Insights, and SHRM workforce data show stronger demand in specializations connected to healthcare, workplace safety, aging populations, and exercise technology.
Clinical exercise physiology: This specialization supports cardiac rehabilitation, diabetes care, chronic disease management, and medically supervised exercise programs. It is one of the stronger choices for students seeking healthcare-aligned stability.
Sports performance coaching: Demand exists in youth sports, collegiate athletics, professional athletics, tactical performance, and private training. Stability varies because funding depends heavily on the employer.
Occupational health and ergonomics: Employers need professionals who can reduce workplace injury risk, improve movement safety, and support compliance with occupational health priorities.
Rehabilitation sciences: Post-injury recovery, mobility restoration, and evidence-based therapeutic exercise keep this area relevant across clinics, hospitals, and outpatient providers.
Wellness program management: Corporate wellness roles remain attractive where employers view health initiatives as part of benefits, retention, productivity, or healthcare cost strategy.
Exercise physiology in aging populations: Older adults need safe, individualized programs for strength, balance, mobility, and chronic condition support.
Exercise technology and data analytics: Wearables, biometric monitoring, athlete tracking, and digital health tools create demand for professionals who can interpret data rather than simply collect it.
Demand is not evenly distributed across the field. A specialization may be popular nationally but weak in a specific region. Before choosing a concentration, compare job postings, internship availability, local healthcare systems, salary surveys, alumni outcomes, and employer credential preferences in the market where you plan to work.
Coursework in physiology, biomechanics, statistics, behavioral change, health assessment, and program design can make graduates more competitive. Practical experience matters just as much. Clinical rotations, internships, research assistantships, athletic department work, and corporate wellness projects help employers see how classroom training translates into job performance. Students trying to enter the workforce more quickly may also evaluate whether an accelerated bachelor's degree fits their timeline and academic readiness.
Which Industries Employing Exercise Science Graduates Offer the Greatest Job Security?
The industries with the greatest job security for exercise science graduates are usually those where movement, rehabilitation, prevention, and health behavior are tied to essential services or institutional priorities. Healthcare and social assistance typically offer the strongest protection, followed by public-sector health, education, selected corporate wellness employers, and well-funded sports or recreation organizations.
Industries with stronger employment protection
Industry
Why it can be stable
Best-fit exercise science skills
Healthcare and Social Assistance
Aging populations, chronic disease management, rehabilitation, and preventive care create persistent demand.
Kinesiology, therapeutic exercise, patient monitoring, mobility assessment, and interdisciplinary communication.
Fitness and Recreational Sports Centers
Wellness interest supports demand, but stability depends on employer size, membership trends, and local income levels.
Exercise programming, coaching, motivation, group training, and biometric assessment.
Educational Services
Schools, colleges, and universities may need fitness, athletics, health education, and performance support roles.
Developmental kinesiology, student assessment, health promotion, and collaboration with educators.
Public Health and Government Agencies
Mandates, grants, and community health programs can support longer-term employment.
Program evaluation, health communication, epidemiology basics, data analysis, and policy implementation.
Corporate Wellness and Insurance
Employers and insurers may invest in prevention, health risk reduction, and employee coaching.
Health risk assessment, behavior change, wellness program design, outcomes tracking, and ROI evaluation.
Healthcare and public-sector roles often provide the best balance of stability and professional relevance. Fitness centers can be useful entry points, but they may be more exposed to economic downturns and consumer spending changes. Corporate wellness can be stable in large organizations, but programs may be reduced if leadership does not see measurable value.
Graduates should avoid building an entire career plan around one narrow employer type. Cross-industry skills such as health data analytics, program management, grant writing, coaching, patient communication, and compliance can make it easier to move from fitness to healthcare, from public health to corporate wellness, or from entry-level programming to management.
: "One public health professional with an exercise science background said that moving beyond exercise prescription into program evaluation and grant writing was difficult at first, but it made her more useful to the agency and improved her long-term job security."
How Do Government and Public-Sector Exercise Science Roles Compare in Unemployment Risk?
Government and public-sector exercise science roles generally carry lower unemployment risk than many private-sector roles, especially during downturns. BLS, OPM, and NASPE sources point to structural protections that can improve stability: civil service rules, public funding cycles, union or collective bargaining agreements in some settings, and the fact that public health and education functions are often less discretionary than consumer fitness services.
Layoff frequency: Federal, state, and local government roles often have more formal review processes before positions are eliminated, reducing sudden job loss compared with some private employers.
Employment stability: Public universities, public health departments, veterans’ health services, state wellness programs, research institutions, and community health agencies may offer steadier tenure when funding is stable.
Compensation trade-off: Starting salaries in public-sector exercise science roles are often lower than private-sector alternatives, but pensions, paid leave, healthcare benefits, and public service loan forgiveness can improve long-term financial security.
Career tenure: Public-sector employees often stay longer because benefits, promotion systems, and job protections reward continuity.
Best-fit candidates: These roles suit graduates who value predictable income, benefits, and mission-driven work more than rapid salary growth or entrepreneurial flexibility.
Main risk: Public-sector jobs are not risk-free. Hiring freezes, grant expirations, political budget changes, and limited promotion openings can slow advancement even when layoffs are uncommon.
The practical comparison is straightforward: private-sector roles may offer higher upside, faster movement, or more specialized performance environments, but they can be more exposed to revenue changes. Public-sector roles may offer slower salary growth but better protection from abrupt unemployment. Students should match the sector to their risk tolerance, debt level, family obligations, and preferred work environment.
What Role Does Licensure or Certification Play in Protecting Exercise Science Degree Holders From Unemployment?
Licensure and certification protect exercise science degree holders by signaling competence, restricting entry into certain roles, and helping employers identify candidates who meet professional standards. In regulated professions, licensure is not optional. In non-regulated roles, respected certifications often function as hiring filters that separate serious candidates from applicants with only general fitness experience.
For physical therapy, occupational therapy, and athletic training, state licensure is a legal requirement. Without the appropriate license, a graduate cannot practice in those roles. That restriction limits labor supply and reduces the ability of employers to replace licensed professionals with cheaper, uncredentialed workers during economic slowdowns.
For roles such as strength and conditioning, wellness coaching, performance coaching, and exercise physiology, certification may not always be legally required, but it can still be decisive. Credentials such as Certified Strength and Conditioning Specialist (CSCS) and American College of Sports Medicine (ACSM) certifications are commonly used to assess readiness, professional commitment, and technical skill.
Mandatory licensure: Physical therapy, occupational therapy, and athletic training require state licensing for practice.
Labor market effect: Licensure constrains the eligible workforce, which can lower unemployment risk for qualified professionals.
Certification value: CSCS and ACSM credentials can improve competitiveness in roles where employers need evidence of specialized training.
Credential sequencing: Prioritize legally required licenses first, then add widely recognized certifications that match your target role.
Cost control: Avoid collecting low-recognition credentials that do not appear in job postings or employer requirements.
Recent trend: The Bureau of Labor Statistics projects a growth of 11% over the next decade for exercise science-related jobs requiring licensure or certification-outpacing overall occupational growth.
The best credential is the one employers in your target market actually request. Before paying for a certification, review job postings, speak with hiring managers, and compare whether the credential is recognized in hospitals, clinics, athletic departments, corporate wellness programs, or performance facilities.
How Does Geographic Location Affect Unemployment Risk for Exercise Science Degree Graduates?
Geographic location can strongly affect unemployment risk for exercise science graduates because jobs are not distributed evenly across the country. Markets with dense healthcare systems, universities, rehabilitation networks, sports organizations, and public health agencies give graduates more ways to find work and recover from layoffs. Metropolitan hubs such as Boston, Minneapolis, and Raleigh are examples of areas known for healthcare corridors and broader institutional employment.
By contrast, smaller markets with fewer hospitals, limited outpatient rehabilitation providers, fewer universities, or weak public health infrastructure may produce longer job searches. In these areas, one hiring freeze or clinic closure can affect a large share of available opportunities. A graduate may be employable on paper but still struggle if the local employer base is too narrow.
How to evaluate a regional market
Count employer types: Look for hospitals, rehabilitation clinics, universities, school systems, sports programs, public agencies, corporate wellness vendors, and fitness employers.
Check job posting depth: A healthy market should show repeated postings across multiple employers, not one or two openings that appear occasionally.
Compare credential requirements: Regions with more clinical employers may value licensure, ACSM credentials, or rehabilitation experience more than general training backgrounds.
Review wage benchmarks: Higher wages may reflect stronger demand, but they can also reflect higher living costs.
Assess remote compatibility: Digital wellness, telehealth fitness coaching, remote exercise physiology consulting, and wellness program design can reduce dependence on a single local market.
Remote work changes the calculation for some specializations but not all. A digital wellness professional may serve clients or employers across regions. A cardiac rehabilitation specialist, athletic trainer, or clinical rehabilitation professional usually needs to be physically present. Students should therefore choose geography and specialization together, not separately.
A practical labor market review should combine BLS metropolitan data, LinkedIn job posting filters by region, and regional wage benchmarks. Recent labor market analysis shows healthcare hubs maintaining unemployment rates for exercise science occupations below the national average, underscoring the value of geographic market selection for job security.
Graduates considering interdisciplinary healthcare paths may also research options such as pharmacy school online accredited, but they should treat that as a separate professional direction with its own admission, licensure, and training requirements.
Which Exercise Science Careers Are Most Vulnerable to Automation and Technological Disruption?
The exercise science careers most vulnerable to automation are the ones built around routine measurement, standardized programming, scheduling, basic data collection, or repetitive client support. McKinsey Global Institute automation susceptibility research, Oxford Martin School occupational automation probability research, and MIT Work of the Future task-level analysis all point to the same pattern: tasks that are predictable and rules-based are easier to automate than work requiring judgment, empathy, adaptation, and accountability.
Fitness assessment technicians: Wearables, mobile health platforms, and AI-driven dashboards can increasingly collect, summarize, and compare biometric data.
Exercise program administrative assistants: Scheduling, intake forms, reminders, document routing, and basic reporting are vulnerable to workflow software and robotic process automation.
Standardized personal training roles: Trainers who deliver generic plans with limited individualization face competition from virtual coaching apps and automated programming tools.
Entry-level rehabilitation support staff: Repetitive monitoring and procedural assistance may be supplemented by robotics, remote monitoring tools, and AI-supported treatment platforms.
The safer roles are not necessarily anti-technology. In fact, many stable careers will require more technology fluency. Clinical exercise physiologists, sports performance specialists, rehabilitation professionals, and advanced coaches may use wearables, force plates, motion capture, remote monitoring, or analytics software. Their value comes from interpreting information, adjusting plans, managing risk, motivating clients, and working within ethical or clinical boundaries.
Automation risk should be treated as a probability, not a prediction of total job loss. Adoption depends on employer budgets, regulation, patient safety concerns, consumer trust, and whether technology is cheaper or better than human labor in a specific setting. A high-risk task may be automated while the broader job evolves rather than disappears.
The best protection is to move from routine delivery to judgment-based practice. Build skills in assessment interpretation, clinical communication, ethical decision-making, technology management, program evaluation, and supervision. If you plan to pivot into nursing or advanced healthcare pathways, a BSN to MSN bridge may be relevant, but it represents a distinct credential path rather than a direct exercise science specialization.
How Does a Graduate Degree Reduce Unemployment Risk for Exercise Science Degree Holders?
A graduate degree can reduce unemployment risk for exercise science degree holders by opening access to specialized, licensed, research, clinical, academic, or management roles that are not available to bachelor’s-level candidates. Data from Georgetown University's Center on Education and the Workforce, BLS statistics, and NACE graduate outcome research consistently show that holding a graduate degree significantly decreases unemployment risk for exercise science degree holders-typically by 2 to 4 percentage points compared to bachelor's degree holders. Advanced credentials also yield salary increases ranging from 15% to 35% across key exercise science career trajectories.
Graduate pathways that can improve stability
Professional master's programs: These can support entry into more specialized clinical or healthcare-related roles, especially when they connect to licensure, supervised practice, or recognized professional standards.
Research-focused master's and doctoral degrees: These prepare graduates for research, academic, laboratory, and specialist positions with smaller applicant pools.
MBA programs: Business training can help exercise science professionals move into management, operations, wellness leadership, sports business, or healthcare administration roles.
Graduate school is not automatically the best unemployment-risk strategy. It can be expensive, time-consuming, and unnecessary for some goals. Tuition and fees usually fall between $20,000 and $60,000 depending on the institution and program. Programs typically last 1 to 3 years, and full-time enrollment can delay earnings and work experience.
Before enrolling, compare graduate education with lower-cost alternatives: targeted certification, relocation to a stronger labor market, supervised clinical experience, employer-funded training, data analytics skills, or a niche specialization. For some students, online fitness degrees may also be worth comparing when flexibility, cost, and continued work experience are important factors.
A graduate degree is most likely to reduce unemployment risk when it leads to a specific outcome: licensure eligibility, a recognized clinical credential, a research role, advancement into management, or access to employers that rarely hire bachelor’s-only candidates. If the program does not clearly change your job options, the return on investment may be weaker.
What Entry-Level Exercise Science Career Paths Offer the Fastest Route to Long-Term Job Stability?
The fastest entry-level routes to long-term stability are roles that help graduates build supervised experience, earn recognized credentials, and move toward regulated or institutionally supported career paths. The first job does not need to be perfect, but it should create a credible next step.
Certified athletic trainer: This path benefits from licensure and continuing education expectations. Advancement often occurs within 3 to 5 years into leadership, specialized therapy, or sports medicine roles.
Physical therapy aide/assistant: These roles provide exposure to rehabilitation settings and can support future movement toward licensed physical therapy, rehabilitation management, or related clinical pathways.
Strength and conditioning coach: Entry-level roles in collegiate, private, tactical, or sports settings can lead to head coach, performance director, or broader wellness leadership roles as networks and credentials grow.
Occupational therapy aide: This can be a practical entry point for graduates considering occupational therapy licensure or rehabilitation-focused advancement. Typical tenure before advancement or certification is 2 to 4 years.
Corporate wellness coordinator: These positions can build transferable skills in health coaching, program design, outcomes tracking, employee engagement, and benefits-related wellness strategy.
When comparing entry-level jobs, do not focus only on starting pay. A slightly lower-paying role at a hospital, university, public agency, or structured wellness organization may create better long-term stability than a higher-paying role with no mentorship, credential pathway, or advancement ladder.
What to look for in a first employer
Clear supervision and training
Support for certification or continuing education
Internal promotion opportunities
Exposure to clinical, performance, or program-management work
Strong regional employer reputation
Low turnover among early-career staff
The strongest early-career strategy is to choose a job that builds both employability and optionality. Graduates who gain clinical exposure, add respected credentials, and work in regions with dense healthcare or performance employers are better positioned for stable mid-career employment.
What Graduates Say About the Exercise Science Degree Careers With the Lowest Unemployment Risk
: "Graduating with an exercise science degree opened doors to sports medicine and rehabilitation, but credentialing made the biggest difference. Earning the Certified Strength and Conditioning Specialist credential early helped me compete for better entry-level roles, especially in a major metropolitan healthcare market. — Arthur"
: "The degree exposed me to wellness centers, corporate fitness, and public health, but I learned that stability depends on where you work and what credentials you add. On the West Coast, employers were especially receptive once I had mid-career credentials like the ACSM EP-C certification. — Roger"
: "Academic and clinical research gave me the most stability because the work was tied to universities and medical facilities. Pairing that environment with a senior-level credential such as the Certified Exercise Physiologist helped me build a more secure long-term path. — Miles"
Other Things You Should Know About Exercise Science Degrees
What does the 10-year employment outlook look like for the safest exercise science career paths?
The 10-year employment outlook for exercise science careers with the lowest unemployment risk is generally positive. Roles such as physical therapists, occupational therapists, and exercise physiologists are projected to grow faster than average due to aging populations and increased focus on preventive health. This steady demand helps sustain job security over the long term for professionals in these specialties.
Which exercise science career tracks lead to the most in-demand mid-career roles?
Mid-career exercise science professionals find the strongest demand in clinical and rehabilitation settings, especially in physical therapy and sports medicine. Specializations involving licensure-like physical therapy and athletic training-tend to offer more job openings with competitive salaries. Due to their blend of clinical expertise and applied science, these tracks show the most sustained opportunities through mid-level stages.
How does freelance or self-employment factor into unemployment risk for exercise science graduates?
Freelance and self-employment opportunities in exercise science can reduce unemployment risk by diversifying income sources and client bases. However, these career paths require strong business skills and networking to maintain consistent work. Graduates choosing entrepreneurship may face more volatility but can also benefit from flexibility and direct control over career direction.
How do economic recessions historically affect unemployment rates in exercise science fields?
Exercise science fields linked to healthcare and rehabilitation tend to be more recession-resistant because health needs persist regardless of economic cycles. Conversely, roles heavily dependent on discretionary spending-such as personal training or wellness coaching-experience higher unemployment spikes during downturns. Overall, careers with credentialing and ties to medical settings show greater employment stability in recessions.