2027 Finding Retractions and Corrections in Nursing Literature Searches
Audited and Verified:
Our Editorial and Data Verification Process
Research.com uses government datasets, official education statistics and primary institutional information to support its career and degree guides. Our review process checks factual accuracy, occupational definitions, source dates and the requirements associated with the credentials discussed.
How This Article Was Fact-Checked
Our editorial team verifies salary estimates, employment projections, education requirements and program information against original data providers and official organizations. Salary figures are checked against the relevant occupational definitions and reporting periods. Information about licensure, accreditation and required in-person training is reviewed separately.
Fact-checked and verified on:
A nursing article can remain in search results, reference lists, and saved PDFs after its findings have been corrected or retracted. For students, clinical educators, and nurse researchers, that can change whether a study belongs in an assignment, evidence review, or practice recommendation.
This guide explains how to find publication updates in PubMed and CINAHL, confirm them with the publisher, judge what remains usable, and document the decision. The goal is to keep an article's publication status from becoming an overlooked source of error.
Key Things You Should Know
- Check both the article and its linked notices: a database record or downloaded PDF may not display the full publication history.
- In PubMed, search publication types such as Retracted Publication, Retraction of Publication, and Published Erratum, in CINAHL, combine title and abstract searches with inspection of the full record.
- A correction does not automatically invalidate a study, but a retracted study should not be used as evidence for a nursing practice claim. Record the status, notice, and date checked.
What are retractions, corrections, and expressions of concern in nursing literature?
These are distinct updates to the scholarly record. Their implications depend on what the notice says, not simply on the label attached to a search result.
The comparison below helps distinguish an article that needs reassessment from one whose findings should no longer support a clinical or scholarly conclusion.
| Publication update | What it usually means | Implication for evidence appraisal |
| Correction or erratum | The publisher identifies and amends an error, which may range from a minor detail to a result or analysis. | Assess whether the corrected information changes the effect estimate, interpretation, or applicability. |
| Expression of concern | The journal alerts readers to a potentially serious unresolved issue. | Treat the findings cautiously and look for a subsequent resolution before relying on them. |
| Retraction | The journal withdraws the article or its findings from the reliable scholarly record. | Do not count the findings as supporting evidence; read the notice to understand its scope and reason. |
A retraction is not, by itself, proof of misconduct, as reasons can include major errors, unreliable data, duplicate publication, or ethical concerns. Conversely, a correction labeled "minor" should still be reviewed if it changes an outcome important to a nursing question, such as medication harm or patient falls. Individuals exploring a career in nursing can also compare online coursework options for aspiring nurses to learn about educational pathways available to students without a nursing background.
How can you find retracted nursing articles in PubMed and CINAHL?
Search the exact article first, then search for its notices. Database coverage and indexing can differ, so a negative result in one database is not confirmation that no update exists.
Use this sequence for an article you might include in a nursing assignment or review:
- In PubMed, search the article title in quotation marks or its DOI. Open the record and inspect publication-type labels and linked notices, including any "Retraction in," "Erratum in," or expression-of-concern information displayed.
- To retrieve labeled records, try retracted publication[pt] for affected articles and retraction of publication[pt] for notices. Search published erratum[pt] when checking corrections; inspect results rather than assuming every linked record is indexed the same way.
- In CINAHL, search the exact title or DOI and open the detailed record. Check title, abstract, publication type where available, and links to related records or publisher full text.
- Repeat the title search with retract*, correction, or expression of concern. Compare any result against the original article's authors, journal, DOI, and publication history.
PubMed's labeled publication types are especially useful for screening indexed records. CINAHL interfaces and available fields vary by institution, so test the search fields in your library's version. Neither database replaces a final check of the journal's article page. Those interested in practical nursing education can also explore short-format LPN coursework and clinical requirements to compare accelerated learning pathways and program expectations.

How do you verify corrections and retractions on publisher websites?
The publisher's article page and formal notice are the primary places to establish what changed. Follow the database record to the journal, or search the journal site using the exact title or DOI. Confirm that the notice refers to the same article; similar titles and author names can lead to a false match.
Read the notice alongside the article's current online version. Look for the notice date, the stated reason, the affected figures or conclusions, and whether a corrected version is available. Check whether the article page links back to the notice and whether the PDF itself carries a status label. An older downloaded PDF may lack a correction that appears on the live page.
If the publisher shows conflicting labels or an inaccessible notice, document what you can verify and ask a health sciences librarian for help. Do not infer from a search-result snippet that an entire study was retracted when the notice may concern a different article or component. Nurses pursuing further education can also explore comparing RN-to-BSN practice expectations to understand how RN-to-BSN programs approach clinical and practical learning requirements.
Search terms should capture both the status of the original article and the separately published notice. Start with an exact title or DOI when checking a known study; use broader terms when screening a set of search results.
These terms cover common notice wording, but they work best when combined with the article title, author, or DOI:
- Retraction: "retracted publication," "retraction of publication," "retraction notice," and retract*.
- Correction: "correction," "erratum," "published erratum," and "corrigendum."
- Unresolved concern: "expression of concern" and, when investigating a specific record, "editorial notice."
In PubMed, a publication-type search is more specific than searching retract* as ordinary text. In CINAHL, try terms in the title and abstract fields and review any publication-type options your interface offers. A broad keyword search may also retrieve articles about retractions rather than notices concerning the study you are checking. Individuals with a non-nursing bachelor's degree who are considering a career transition can also explore online graduate-entry MSN pathways to compare accelerated graduate nursing education options.
Crossmark is a publisher-used tool that can display an article's update status. When a Crossmark button appears on a journal article or PDF, open it and inspect the status information and any linked correction, retraction, or other update. Match the DOI shown to the article under review.
Crossmark is a useful additional check, not a universal clearance certificate. Not every publisher or article uses it, and the information available depends on participating publishers' registered updates. An absent button or a record showing no update does not rule out a notice elsewhere. Check the publisher's article page and relevant database records as well. Students preparing to apply to accelerated nursing programs can also explore ABSN application planning by selectivity to compare admission requirements and program selectivity.

Judge the effect of the correction on your question, not just whether the article still appears online. A corrected affiliation may leave the analysis unchanged. A corrected adverse-event count, outcome definition, or statistical result could change whether the study supports a patient-safety conclusion.
Compare the notice with the version you planned to use. Identify which results changed, whether the authors revised their conclusions, and whether your review's extracted data must be replaced. Then reassess study design, bias, and relevance using the corrected information. If the notice is unclear about a result central to your question, do not treat the original number as settled evidence; seek clarification through the journal or report the uncertainty.
For a nursing evidence review, this distinction prevents two opposite errors: discarding a usable study over a non-substantive correction and retaining a study whose corrected results no longer support the proposed practice change. Students exploring nursing education can also review nursing admission options beyond highly selective programs to compare schools with potentially more accessible admission requirements.
Do not cite a retracted article as evidence that a clinical intervention works, a harm occurs at a particular rate, or a practice recommendation is justified. If the retraction itself matters - for example, in a discussion of research integrity or the history of an evidence base - identify the article as retracted in the surrounding text and cite the retraction notice as well as the original article where needed.
Follow the required citation style when formatting the two reference entries. Citation rules differ, but accurate labeling is essential: an ordinary reference to the original article can make withdrawn findings appear current. If an included study is retracted after a review is drafted, remove it from the supporting evidence, revisit the synthesis, and explain any resulting change in conclusions. Students researching nursing education can also explore nursing program options without HESI scores to compare schools with alternative admission testing requirements.
The Retraction Watch Database can provide another way to investigate an article or identify a notice that a routine topical search missed. Search by title, DOI, author, or journal, then compare the entry with the article and the publisher's formal notice.
Use it as a discovery and cross-checking resource, not as the final authority on an article's status. Database coverage, record details, and the timing of updates can vary. If an entry flags a study used in a nursing review, confirm the match and the reason for retraction at the journal before changing your evidence table. If no entry appears, continue checking PubMed, CINAHL, and the publisher. LPNs planning to advance their careers can also explore accelerated RN bridge options for LPNs to compare pathways toward registered nursing.
Build status checks into the review workflow rather than waiting until the reference list is finished. A check at screening catches obvious problems; a second check before submission catches notices issued during the project.
For a course review, evidence-based practice project, or research synthesis, use these checkpoints:
- At full-text screening, record each potentially included study's DOI or other stable identifier and inspect its database record and publisher page for notices.
- Before extracting outcomes, read any correction or expression of concern and decide whether the study remains eligible under the review's criteria.
- Keep notices linked to their original studies in the citation manager or screening record so a notice is not mistaken for a separate intervention study.
- Before submission or a practice presentation, recheck included studies and key citations. If a new retraction appears, revise the synthesis and any recommendation that depended on it.
A documented status check improves reproducibility, but it cannot guarantee that every future problem will be identified. Reviews used to inform care also need routine appraisal of study quality and alignment with current clinical guidance. "Not retracted" does not automatically mean "high-quality evidence." Nurses considering graduate education can also explore BSN-to-MSN tuition comparisons to compare affordable bridge programs and evaluate potential pathways for career advancement.
How should nursing students document literature corrections and retractions?
Keep a brief audit trail that lets an instructor, faculty advisor, or review teammate understand the decision without repeating the entire search. In an evidence table or screening log, record the original article's citation and DOI, the notice type and citation, the publisher's stated change, the date checked, and your decision to include, reassess, or exclude the study.
For example, a defensible note might say: "Correction changes the fall-rate denominator; extracted outcome replaced using corrected version; eligibility unchanged." For a retraction, specify which finding was removed from the synthesis. If the status remains unresolved, state that limitation rather than presenting the article as verified.
Use institutional library access and approved project records when saving notices. Do not place patient information or confidential clinical-site material in a literature-search log. The deliverable is a transparent evidence decision, not a claim that the student has independently investigated the publisher's underlying data. Nurses with an associate degree who are considering graduate education can also explore graduate nursing routes for associate-degree nurses to compare available pathways toward an MSN.
Other Things You Should Know About Nursing
A preprint server may withdraw, remove, or label a posted manuscript under its own policies. Check the preprint page for version and status information, and do not assume a later journal article has the same content or publication status.
Check whether the guideline has been updated and whether its recommendation relies materially on that study. Do not revise clinical practice on your own; raise the discrepancy through the appropriate instructor, guideline owner, or institutional evidence-review process.
No. Some tools display retraction alerts, but coverage and syncing vary. Treat alerts as prompts to verify a record, and keep a manual final check in the workflow.
No. Journal publication establishes neither permanent validity nor fitness for a particular nursing question. Check its current status and appraise its methods, findings, and relevance.
- Help - PubMed - NIH https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/help/
- Systematic Reviews | CDC Library https://www.cdc.gov/library/research-guides/systematic-reviews.html
- Errata, Retractions, and Other Linked Citations in PubMed | nih.gov https://www.nlm.nih.gov/bsd/policy/errata.html
- Health (Nursing, Medicine, Allied Health): Selecting Databases | Research Guides at New York University https://guides.nyu.edu/health/selecting-databases
- Retractions in PubMed - Retraction of Scholarly Articles - Research Guides https://libguides.cmich.edu/retraction/pubmed
- Tracking Your Publications: Retraction Resources - LibGuides | LibGuides at Texas Medical Center Library https://libguides.library.tmc.edu/tracking-your-publications/retraction-resources
- What about errata and retractions? - Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses - Research Guides at Virginia Tech https://guides.lib.vt.edu/SRMA/retractions
- Reducing the residue of retractions in evidence synthesis | bmj.com https://ebm.bmj.com/content/29/2/121