2027 Pilot Studies vs Feasibility Studies in Nursing Research
Audited and Verified:
Our Editorial and Data Verification Process
Research.com uses government datasets, official education statistics and primary institutional information to support its career and degree guides. Our review process checks factual accuracy, occupational definitions, source dates and the requirements associated with the credentials discussed.
How This Article Was Fact-Checked
Our editorial team verifies salary estimates, employment projections, education requirements and program information against original data providers and official organizations. Salary figures are checked against the relevant occupational definitions and reporting periods. Information about licensure, accreditation and required in-person training is reviewed separately.
Fact-checked and verified on:
A nursing intervention can be promising yet impossible to test as planned: patients may be hard to recruit, nurses may lack time to deliver it, or outcome data may be incomplete. Pilot and feasibility studies help researchers discover those problems before committing to a larger study. For nursing students, clinicians, and graduate researchers, the distinction matters when choosing a design, setting success criteria, and interpreting findings.
This guide explains which approach fits your question and how to turn a small study into a defensible next step.
Key Things You Should Know
- Feasibility studies ask whether a proposed study or intervention can be done and what must change; pilot studies are feasibility studies that rehearse part or all of the planned larger study.
- Recruitment, retention, intervention delivery, fidelity, safety, and usable data usually matter more than a preliminary treatment-effect estimate. A hypothetical 15 of 20 participants retained is 75%, but that small result is uncertain.
- Set decision criteria before collecting data. A small statistically significant result does not establish clinical effectiveness or justify skipping a properly designed larger study.
What is the difference between pilot studies and feasibility studies in nursing research?
A feasibility study investigates whether a proposed intervention or research process is workable. It might examine whether a hospital can supply eligible participants, whether nurses can deliver a protocol during routine shifts, or whether patients understand a questionnaire. It need not reproduce the eventual study design.
A pilot study is a particular kind of feasibility study: a small-scale rehearsal of the intended larger study, often including its recruitment, allocation, intervention, follow-up, and data-collection procedures. In the terminology used by the CONSORT extension for randomized pilot and feasibility trials, all pilot studies address feasibility, but not every feasibility study is a pilot.
The distinction also applies to nursing education research. Investigating whether students can participate in nontraditional practice formats in RN-to-BSN programs is a feasibility question; rehearsing the planned comparison and its assessment schedule with a small group would be a pilot.
When should nursing researchers use a feasibility study instead of a pilot study?
Choose a broader feasibility study when you do not yet know whether the intervention, setting, population, or measurement strategy is workable. If a nurse-led discharge intervention has no agreed workflow, it is premature to rehearse a full trial. Interviews with bedside nurses, a review of eligible patient counts, and a short test of the documentation process may answer the immediate questions more efficiently.
Choose a pilot when the intervention and larger-study design are sufficiently specified to test their procedures together. The decision is about readiness to rehearse, not whether the project is important or whether it belongs to a particular degree. A DNP student weighing admission-focused nursing practice doctorate comparisons, for example, should still verify the chosen program's project requirements; a local workflow feasibility assessment is not automatically a pilot trial or a required dissertation.

How do pilot and feasibility studies support larger nursing research projects?
They reduce avoidable uncertainty before a larger project consumes more staff time, participant effort, and funding. A study may show that recruitment is slower than expected, weekend follow-up is routinely missed, or an electronic health record field does not capture the intended outcome. Researchers can then revise the protocol, change sites, select a better measure, or decide not to proceed.
Investigators should record which findings trigger each decision and distinguish a revised intervention from the one originally tested. An external pilot is analyzed separately from the later definitive study. An internal pilot may contribute participants to that study only if the protocol prospectively specifies the arrangement and any changes preserve the validity of the combined analysis.
Planning matters even for time-limited doctoral work. Someone comparing short online Doctor of Nursing Practice degrees should check whether the actual project timeline allows for site permission, review, recruitment, and revision—not assume a small pilot can bypass those steps.
The strongest questions concern a decision the research team must make. "Can eligible patients be identified and enrolled during discharge?" is more useful at this stage than "Does the intervention improve outcomes?" if recruitment itself remains uncertain.
For example, a team studying accelerated mental health NP master's coursework could first ask whether students and clinical instructors can complete planned interviews and assessments on schedule. If it then rehearses the full comparison, including allocation and follow-up, that work becomes a pilot of the proposed study.
In clinical research, questions might concern whether patients accept remote symptom monitoring, whether different shifts deliver a nurse-led intervention consistently, or whether follow-up data can be obtained without overburdening participants. Each question should lead to an observable measure and a stated decision about what happens next.
Start with the proposed larger study, then identify what is most uncertain about carrying it out. The design should test those uncertainties without exposing participants to procedures that are unnecessary for that purpose.
- Specify the next study: Define the population, setting, intervention, comparison if applicable, and proposed primary outcome.
- Identify the bottlenecks: Check access to participants, staff capacity across shifts, site permissions, data availability, and the burden of follow-up.
- Choose proportionate methods: Use interviews or observations for acceptability and workflow questions; rehearse the intended trial procedures when a pilot is warranted.
- Predefine decisions: State what results would support proceeding unchanged, proceeding with revisions, or stopping.
- Arrange oversight and documentation: Confirm required institutional review, consent, privacy controls, staff responsibilities, and a plan for recording protocol changes.
Site access deserves particular attention. In a study involving NP trainees, comparing clinical site support for FNP students may help frame a question about placement logistics, but advertised support is not permission to recruit at a clinical site. The school and site must authorize any proposed activity and data access.

Measure outcomes that determine whether the larger study can run and whether its procedures are acceptable and safe. Clinical outcomes may be collected to test measurement procedures, but they are generally not the primary basis for declaring effectiveness.
The following measures cover common nursing-specific risks to study delivery; researchers should select only those tied to their decision criteria.
- Recruitment and retention: Eligible patients or students identified, enrolled, and followed, including reasons for nonparticipation or withdrawal.
- Delivery and fidelity: Whether nurses can deliver the intended components across shifts, sites, and staffing conditions, and whether any adaptations occur.
- Acceptability and burden: Participant and staff feedback, time required, interruptions to care, and accessibility barriers.
- Data quality and safety: Missing or unusable measures, adverse events, privacy incidents, and problems with documentation or escalation.
Resource measures can matter too. If a proposed project concerns students choosing based on psychiatric NP program affordability comparisons, collecting tuition figures alone would miss travel, placement, and lost-work costs that affect participation. Define the costs relevant to the research question before collecting them.
Neither label determines a standard sample size. A qualitative feasibility study might recruit enough participants to examine a specific workflow across relevant roles or shifts. A pilot randomized trial needs enough participants to test randomization, delivery, and follow-up but is usually too small to provide a reliable treatment-effect estimate.
Base the sample-size justification on the feasibility objective: the precision needed around a recruitment or retention estimate, the range of settings or perspectives to examine, or the practicality of rehearsing procedures. Report counts, proportions, uncertainty intervals where useful, and clearly described qualitative findings. Avoid treating a nonsignificant clinical comparison as proof of no benefit—or a significant one as proof of effectiveness. Small-study effect estimates can be unstable and should not be used uncritically as the sole basis for a definitive trial's sample size.
Budget and burden also constrain a defensible design. In research about budget-conscious NP education pathways, for instance, a small convenience sample may reveal problems with a cost survey but cannot establish what all US NP students pay.
Small scale does not remove obligations to protect participants. Obtain the institution's required determination before recruitment or data access; an IRB or authorized office, not the researcher alone, decides whether an activity is human-subjects research and what review applies. Also secure site permission, use appropriate consent procedures, limit access to identifiable records, and plan how clinical concerns or adverse events will be handled.
Describe the study by what it actually did. For a randomized pilot or feasibility trial, the CONSORT extension for randomized pilot and feasibility trials provides a relevant reporting framework: make the feasibility objectives, prespecified criteria, recruitment flow, protocol changes, harms, and limitations clear. Other designs require reporting appropriate to their methods and any journal or institutional requirements.
For example, recruiting nurses from short PMHNP certificate pathways for nurses still requires appropriate permission and safeguards for student information. Participation should not be confused with a course or clinical requirement unless the approved study explicitly addresses that relationship.
Read the stated objective before reading the conclusion. If the objective was to test whether nurses could deliver an intervention during overnight shifts, judge the study chiefly on its delivery evidence—not on a headline about an exploratory patient outcome.
Check whether the authors defined success in advance, enrolled the population they intended to reach, reported missing data and departures from the protocol, and explained how the findings change the proposed larger study. Ask whether results from one unit, school, or site plausibly apply to another with different staffing or resources.
This appraisal applies to education research as well as bedside studies. A small interview study of applicants considering ADN-to-MSN admission requirements might identify confusing application steps; it cannot establish the admission rate or success of every bridge program. Use a feasibility report to assess the next research decision, not to infer an outcome it was not designed to establish.
What common mistakes should researchers avoid when labeling these studies?
The most consequential error is calling any small study a pilot. A study becomes a pilot by rehearsing a planned larger study, not by having few participants. Conversely, calling a workflow interview study "not research" simply because it examines feasibility does not settle its oversight requirements.
Other mistakes include omitting a proposed next study, inventing success thresholds after seeing the results, treating a preliminary clinical effect as definitive, and failing to report that staffing or procedures changed mid-study. Labels should accurately reflect the design, including when a project is a local quality-improvement activity rather than a pilot of a research trial.
Short timelines can make imprecise labels tempting. Whether a student is comparing 12-month family NP programs or planning a longer research degree, the defensible approach is the same: describe what was tested, who authorized it, what the data support, and what remains unknown.
Other Things You Should Know About Nursing
Yes. A clearly reported feasibility study can make a useful contribution when its methods, limitations, and implications for future research are explicit. Publication does not require a positive clinical effect.
No. Quality improvement and research can use similar measures but have different purposes and oversight pathways. Describe the project's actual aim and obtain the required institutional determination rather than assigning a label yourself.
Yes. Evidence that recruitment, delivery, or measurement will not work as planned can prevent a larger, poorly designed study and guide a specific revision - or a decision to stop.
No. Programs set their own project or dissertation expectations. Confirm the required scope, design, approvals, and milestones with the faculty advisor and program before treating a proposed study as an approved academic deliverable.
- Guidelines for Designing and Evaluating Feasibility Pilot Studies | nih.gov https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC8849521/
- Applying mixed methods to pilot feasibility studies to inform intervention trials - PMC https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC9511762/
- What is the difference between feasibility studies and pilot testing? | Division of Research and Innovation https://research.oregonstate.edu/ori/irb/what-difference-between-feasibility-studies-and-pilot-testing
- CONSORT 2010 statement: extension to randomised pilot and feasibility trials | The BMJ https://www.bmj.com/content/355/bmj.i5239
- Definition of feasibility studies and pilot studies. | clinmedjournals.org https://clinmedjournals.org/articles/ianhc/ianhc-7-153-table1.html