2027 Bullying and Incivility in Nursing: Recognizing Workplace Patterns and Support Routes
Audited and Verified:
Our Editorial and Data Verification Process
Research.com uses government datasets, official education statistics and primary institutional information to support its career and degree guides. Our review process checks factual accuracy, occupational definitions, source dates and the requirements associated with the credentials discussed.
How This Article Was Fact-Checked
Our editorial team verifies salary estimates, employment projections, education requirements and program information against original data providers and official organizations. Salary figures are checked against the relevant occupational definitions and reporting periods. Information about licensure, accreditation and required in-person training is reviewed separately.
Fact-checked and verified on:
A nurse who is repeatedly excluded from handoff, mocked for asking questions, or discouraged from reporting a safety concern needs more than advice to "be resilient." Bullying and incivility can affect clinical communication, learning, and decisions about staying in a job. This guide helps nursing students, new graduates, and working nurses distinguish harmful patterns from ordinary feedback, document and escalate concerns, and identify support. It also explains when education or a different workplace may help - and why another degree is rarely the first remedy for mistreatment.
Key Things You Should Know
- Look for patterns and consequences: repeated humiliation, exclusion from essential information, and retaliation warrant attention even when each incident appears minor.
- Record dates, exact conduct, witnesses, and effects on work; report immediate patient-safety risks through the appropriate clinical channel rather than waiting for an HR investigation.
- A CDC analysis found reported workplace harassment among U.S. health workers rose from 6.4% in 2018 to 13.4% in 2022. Those figures are not a current nurse-specific bullying rate, but they underscore why employers need credible reporting and support systems.
What are bullying and incivility in nursing workplaces?
Incivility is disrespectful conduct such as dismissive remarks, eye-rolling, or interruptions. Bullying generally describes repeated, harmful behavior directed at someone who has difficulty defending themselves because of a power imbalance. A supervisor can create that imbalance, but so can an influential peer, preceptor, or group. Workplace policies may define these terms differently.
A single rude interaction may need correction without establishing a bullying pattern. Conversely, one serious threat or act of violence requires prompt action even if it has never happened before. Direct, respectful correction of a medication error is not bullying simply because it feels uncomfortable; public ridicule, deliberate withholding of information, or punishment for speaking up is different. Assess the conduct, its context, and whether it interferes with safe practice - not just the label someone applies to it. Building a supportive culture starts long before clinical practice, often when students are still comparing nursing application competitiveness and evaluating which programs prioritize healthy learning environments.
How do bullying and incivility affect nurses, patients, and care quality?
Mistreatment can make nurses reluctant to ask for clarification, escalate a change in condition, or seek help with an unfamiliar task. It can also disrupt orientation, contribute to stress, and influence turnover decisions. These are plausible safety pathways, not proof that every rude encounter causes a patient injury.
For a student or new graduate, the distinction between learning and independent competence matters—a foundational consideration even during direct-entry MSN admission planning when selecting programs with strong clinical mentorship. A nurse who hesitates to consult a preceptor may miss a chance for supervised correction; a student should not be expected to perform beyond their assigned scope to avoid criticism. The CDC's 2018-2022 harassment figures describe U.S. health workers across occupations and a specific historical period. They cannot establish the present rate of bullying among nurses or predict what will happen on a particular unit.

What workplace patterns commonly indicate bullying or incivility in nursing?
Patterns become easier to recognize when you compare how people are treated across similar shifts, assignments, and levels of experience. Pay particular attention to behavior that obstructs information exchange or learning:
- Repeatedly excluding one nurse from handoff details, team messages, or opportunities to ask safety-critical questions.
- Mocking a student or new hire in front of patients or staff instead of giving specific, private, actionable feedback when feasible.
- Assigning unusually difficult work without appropriate support, then criticizing the nurse for requesting help.
- Spreading rumors, threatening poor evaluations for raising concerns, or repeatedly undermining agreed-upon instructions.
High workload or a blunt communication style does not excuse unsafe conduct, but neither proves intent. Compare assignments and feedback against unit policy, staffing conditions, and documented competency expectations—principles of transparent evaluation that prospective students also look for when reviewing a guide to nursing schools with no TEAS or HESI to find holistic, supportive academic programs. A clear pattern - and its effect on work - is more useful to an investigator than speculation about a colleague's motives.
Separate an immediate clinical risk from the employment complaint. If essential information is missing during handoff or a patient may be harmed, use the chain of command and applicable safety-reporting process at once. An HR complaint should not replace clinical escalation.
For a developing pattern, use a factual sequence that another person can assess:
- Record the date, time, location, people present, conduct or exact words when remembered, and your response soon after the incident.
- Describe the work impact precisely: for example, which handoff information you requested and when you received it. Distinguish what you observed from what you inferred.
- Review the employer's conduct, retaliation, and reporting policies. Report to the designated supervisor or HR contact; if that person is involved, use the alternate channel in the policy.
- Keep a record of your report, requested follow-up, and subsequent events. Ask how patient-safety concerns will be handled while the employment issue is reviewed.
Keep personal notes secure and free of patient identifiers. Do not export charts, take photos of records, or send confidential employer material to a personal account to build a case. Use authorized systems for patient-safety reports, and follow applicable record-retention and privacy rules. If you are a student—such as a working nurse balancing clinical rotations alongside LPN-to-RN bridge completion timelines—involve your clinical faculty or placement coordinator as well as the site's designated reporting contact.
The best route depends on the conduct and what needs to change. A trusted preceptor or educator may help resolve a misunderstanding about expectations; a manager or HR representative can address repeated conduct and assignments. When the manager is involved, look for an alternate reporting line, higher-level leader, ombudsperson, or union representative if available. An employee assistance program or personal clinician can help with stress without replacing a workplace investigation.
Some concerns require a separate channel. Report threats or imminent danger to security or emergency services. Use the clinical chain of command for current patient-safety risks. Discrimination or harassment tied to a protected characteristic may warrant advice about an Equal Employment Opportunity Commission or state-agency complaint; deadlines and protections depend on the facts and jurisdiction. A state nursing board may be relevant to conduct within its regulatory authority, but it is not a general substitute for HR. Ask each contact what it can investigate, what confidentiality it can offer, and how retaliation concerns are handled.
If the workplace does not respond, consider whether a transfer or new employer offers a safer path—or even advancing your credentials through accelerated nursing programs with broader entry criteria to transition into a clinical environment with stronger support. Before accepting another position, ask about orientation length, preceptor access, staffing escalation, turnover, and how leaders respond when a new nurse raises a concern. Leaving a harmful unit is not an admission that the conduct was acceptable.

Preparation should connect respectful communication to clinical judgment, not merely require students to sign a professionalism statement—a vital curriculum standard to look for when reviewing a guide to nursing degrees without an RN background and evaluating how programs prepare career changers for clinical environments. Coursework and simulation can let students practice assertive handoff questions, feedback conversations, speaking up across hierarchies, and reporting a concern while protecting patient privacy. Clinical faculty then need to observe how students apply those skills and explain what to do when a placement-site employee is the source of mistreatment.
Students should know who evaluates their clinical performance, how to contest an inaccurate evaluation, and whether raising a concern could affect placement or progression. Ask the school how it responds when a site cannot provide a safe learning environment, including whether an alternate placement is possible. Simulation builds readiness; it does not replace supervised clinical assessment or guarantee that every clinical site has a respectful culture.
A degree can support a longer-term move into education, improvement, or management, but it is not required to document mistreatment, seek help, or advocate for safe care. For many nurses, mentoring, shared-governance participation, employer leadership training, or a better-supported unit is the more direct first step.
The pathways below differ in entry point and likely use; none automatically grants supervisory authority or fixes a workplace culture.
| Pathway | Relevant preparation | Best fit for this goal |
| Prelicensure ADN or BSN | Foundational nursing practice and supervised clinical learning | Entering RN practice and assessing employers' orientation and support |
| Postlicensure RN-to-BSN | Additional study that may include leadership, population health, and evidence appraisal | Licensed RNs seeking a bachelor's credential for roles that require or prefer it |
| Non-APRN MSN or DNP in leadership or education | Advanced preparation for organizational change, staff development, or practice improvement | Experienced nurses pursuing specified roles with verified employer requirements |
An LPN/LVN or ADN-prepared nurse should first check the license and degree required by the target job; nursing master's bridges for ADN graduates are worth comparing only when graduate study serves a defined goal. An education or leadership MSN or DNP does not by itself prepare someone for nurse practitioner licensure. Compare the required credential with the time, tuition, clinical or project obligations, and experience an employer expects before enrolling.
Start with the intended license or role, then verify three distinct matters: the institution's accreditation, any applicable nursing program accreditation, and state board approval for a prelicensure program. Confirm eligibility in the jurisdiction where you intend to practice. A school's general accreditation does not, by itself, establish that a particular nursing track qualifies graduates for licensure.
Professional culture deserves its own questions. Request the student conduct and grievance policies; ask who receives complaints about clinical-site staff, how students obtain an alternate contact when faculty are involved, and what happens if a placement becomes unsuitable. Look for evidence that communication and escalation are assessed during clinical learning, not just described in a course catalog. Speak with current students when possible, while recognizing that individual experiences may differ.
Career changers considering entry-level MSN options for career changers should confirm that a specific program provides initial RN preparation rather than assuming every MSN does. Whatever the format, ask about required on-site learning, placement responsibility, scheduling, total cost, and the policy that will apply to your entry cohort. A short advertised timeline is less useful than a credible clinical experience and a clear reporting route.
A school award, license, specialty certification, and employer competency sign-off serve different purposes. Graduating from an approved prelicensure RN program can support application for NCLEX-RN eligibility, but the state board makes the licensing decision. LPN/LVN applicants follow their applicable program and NCLEX-PN pathway. An RN entering a new unit still needs employer orientation and demonstrated setting-specific competence.
Leadership and educator jobs vary: some require an active RN license and practice experience, while others prefer graduate education or a professional certification. Check the actual job description and the certifying organization's current eligibility criteria before paying for a credential. If the goal is advanced practice, verify a role- and population-focused educational track, applicable national certification, and state APRN requirements. A non-APRN leadership degree does not substitute for that preparation.
What salary and job outlook can nursing graduates expect?
U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics wage and employment projections describe occupations, not what a graduate of a particular degree will earn or whether a given unit is supportive. Registered-nurse figures are most relevant to RN job decisions; they should not be used as a stand-in for nurse manager, faculty, or advanced practice pay. Pay also varies by location, shift, setting, experience, and employer.
When comparing an offer with additional education, request the actual pay range and advancement criteria for the target role. Then weigh tuition, fees, time away from work, and any employer assistance against the likelihood that the credential changes your eligibility. If the immediate problem is bullying, a higher-paying credential can wait: evaluate whether the employer will address the conduct and whether another team offers safer support.
Other Things You Should Know About Nursing
Yes. You can request a temporary scheduling, preceptor, or reporting-line change and explain any safety concern. The employer or school decides what arrangements are feasible; ask how the change will affect your assignments or clinical progression.
Do not assume it is. Recording laws vary by state, and workplace rules and patient privacy may impose additional limits. Seek appropriate advice before recording rather than risking an unauthorized disclosure.
Tell the charge nurse or supervisor promptly and follow the site's threat, visitor, and incident-reporting procedures. A patient's care needs do not require staff to manage threats alone; the response must also respect patient-care obligations.
Not necessarily. Details of an incident may make the reporter recognizable, and anonymity can limit follow-up. Ask the reporting office what it can keep confidential, who may receive the information, and how to report suspected retaliation.
- Interventions for Preventing and Resolving Bullying in Nursing | nih.gov https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10815476/
- Disruptive and Unprofessional Behavior | PSNet https://psnet.ahrq.gov/primer/disruptive-and-unprofessional-behavior
- Practice - Peer Review: Incident-Based or Safe Harbor https://www.bon.texas.gov/practice_peer_review.asp.html
- Violence, Bullying, Incivility | cdc.gov https://www.cdc.gov/niosh/learning/safetyculturehc/module-2/10.html
- Workplace Violence | ANA https://www.nursingworld.org/practice-policy/work-environment/wpv/
- Interventions for Preventing and Resolving Bullying in Nursing: A Scoping Review | mdpi.com https://www.mdpi.com/2227-9032/12/2/280