2026 Which Industries Offer the Best Career Paths for Applied Business & Technology Degree Graduates?

Imed Bouchrika, PhD

by Imed Bouchrika, PhD

Co-Founder and Chief Data Scientist

Which Industries Offer the Highest Starting Salaries for Applied Business & Technology Degree Graduates?

The highest starting salaries for applied business & technology graduates are usually found in industries where employers need people who can translate technical systems into measurable business results. Recent data from the Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) points to several strong-paying sectors for entry-level professionals, especially where digital transformation, compliance pressure, automation, and data-driven decision-making are central to operations.

  • Information Technology: IT remains one of the strongest starting-salary markets because employers need graduates who understand cybersecurity, data analytics, systems integration, cloud operations, and business process improvement. Entry-level roles can include business systems analyst, IT project coordinator, data operations associate, and technology implementation specialist.
  • Financial Services: Banks, investment firms, insurance companies, and fintech employers pay for professionals who can work across business strategy, risk, compliance, data platforms, and customer-facing financial technology. Graduates who are comfortable with analytics and regulatory requirements may find especially competitive early-career opportunities.
  • Healthcare Technology: Healthcare organizations need professionals who can improve administrative systems, protect data, support electronic health records, and use analytics to improve operations. Because health systems depend on reliable technology and face labor shortages, starting pay can be attractive for graduates with both business and technical fluency.
  • Engineering Services: Consulting and technical services firms value employees who can coordinate projects, analyze workflows, support client systems, and communicate between engineers, managers, and customers. The technical complexity of the work often supports above-average entry-level compensation.
  • Management Consulting: Consulting firms hire applied business & technology graduates to support digital strategy, process redesign, operations improvement, and technology adoption. Compensation can be strong, but expectations around travel, deadlines, and client service may be demanding.
  • Telecommunications: Network modernization, broadband expansion, wireless infrastructure, and enterprise connectivity create demand for professionals who understand both technology platforms and business operations. Roles may involve project coordination, service delivery, data reporting, or systems support.
  • Manufacturing Technology: Automation, robotics, supply chain analytics, and smart manufacturing systems have increased the need for graduates who can improve production, logistics, procurement, and quality processes. Starting salaries may be strongest in firms investing heavily in modernization.

Starting salary should not be the only filter. A high initial offer may come with longer hours, higher performance pressure, less stability, or limited mentoring. A lower starting salary may be worth considering if the industry offers clear promotions, employer-funded certifications, strong benefits, or better work-life balance.

Before deciding, compare each industry on four questions: How fast can you advance? How stable is hiring during downturns? Are remote or hybrid roles common? What credentials will you need after graduation? Students still evaluating academic pathways can also review college majors with strong career prospects to see how business and technology preparation compares with other fields.

Table of contents

What Are the Fastest-Growing Industries Actively Hiring Applied Business & Technology Graduates Today?

The fastest-growing industries for applied business & technology graduates are those where technology is no longer a support function but a core part of service delivery, compliance, operations, and customer experience. The U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) projects sustained above-average job growth in sectors shaped by demographic change, digitization, infrastructure investment, and shifting consumer behavior.

  • Healthcare and Social Assistance: Aging populations, expanded healthcare access, and the growth of digital care systems create demand for graduates who can work in health information management, operations analytics, scheduling systems, revenue cycle technology, and digital transformation projects.
  • Information Technology and Services: Cloud computing, cybersecurity, artificial intelligence, software platforms, and managed IT services continue to create roles for professionals who can coordinate projects, analyze business needs, manage vendors, and align technology investments with organizational goals.
  • Renewable Energy and Environmental Technologies: Climate policies and infrastructure investments are expanding opportunities in solar, wind, energy storage, environmental compliance, and sustainability operations. Applied business & technology graduates may support project management, reporting systems, procurement, and process optimization.
  • Financial Services and Fintech: Digital banking, automated investment tools, payment platforms, fraud detection, and regulatory technology have increased demand for hybrid business-technology roles. Graduates with data, compliance, and customer systems knowledge may be well positioned.
  • Logistics and E-commerce: Online shopping, complex supply chains, last-mile delivery, and warehouse automation require professionals who can improve business processes through technology. Roles often involve analytics, inventory systems, operations coordination, and vendor platforms.

Not all hiring growth is equally durable. Construction and some manufacturing employers may add jobs quickly during economic expansions or stimulus-driven investment cycles, but hiring can slow when demand falls. Healthcare, IT, renewable energy, fintech, and logistics are more closely tied to structural changes that may support longer-term hiring.

Graduates should evaluate growth alongside job quality. Look at training programs, promotion history, turnover, remote-work policies, benefits, and whether the work builds transferable skills. If cost is a major concern while strengthening business credentials, a cheap online business degree may help some students add managerial preparation without taking on unnecessary expense.

How Does Industry Choice Affect Long-Term Earning Potential for Applied Business & Technology Professionals?

Industry choice can matter as much as job title when it comes to long-term earning potential. Two graduates may begin in similar analyst or coordinator roles, but their income paths can diverge sharply depending on promotion structures, bonus eligibility, equity compensation, employer profitability, and demand for specialized skills.

  • High-growth income paths: Technology, finance, consulting, and healthcare technology often offer faster salary progression because employees can move into product, analytics, compliance, operations leadership, or digital transformation roles. In some cases, wages may double or triple within 10 to 15 years, especially for professionals who gain leadership responsibility or specialized technical expertise.
  • Slower-growth income paths: Education, nonprofit organizations, government contractors with fixed budgets, and some manufacturing environments may offer steadier employment but narrower salary bands. These roles can still be valuable, but pay may plateau if promotion ladders are limited.
  • Total compensation differences: Salary is only one piece of earnings. Technology companies may offer stock options or restricted stock units. Finance and consulting employers may offer performance bonuses. Government and budget-limited fields often provide fewer variable incentives but may compensate through benefits, retirement plans, or job security.
  • Skill compounding: Industries that invest heavily in training, certifications, mentorship, and internal mobility can improve long-term earnings because employees build marketable experience faster.

A smart salary comparison looks beyond the first offer. Ask how compensation typically changes after three years, whether promotions are formal or informal, whether managers support certification, and how bonuses or equity are calculated. A role with a slightly lower starting salary may be financially stronger over time if it leads to management responsibility, high-demand technical specialization, or a more portable professional network.

One applied business & technology graduate described the learning curve this way: “Joining a tech firm after graduation was exciting, but I had to learn how stock options, bonuses, and base salary worked together. My early years were about building expertise and understanding total rewards, not just chasing the highest starting number. The biggest gains came after I aligned my skills with an industry that invested in employee growth.”

Which Industries Provide the Most Stable and Recession-Proof Careers for Applied Business & Technology Graduates?

The most stable career paths for applied business & technology graduates are usually found in industries that provide essential services, operate under long-term funding models, or must continue investing in technology regardless of the economic cycle. During downturns such as the 2008 financial crisis and the 2020 COVID-19 pandemic, healthcare, government, public administration, cybersecurity, and some compliance-focused roles showed stronger resilience than many discretionary or consumer-sensitive fields.

Healthcare is one of the clearest examples. Hospitals, insurers, clinics, and health technology vendors still need business systems, data management, billing platforms, compliance support, scheduling tools, and health informatics expertise even when the broader economy weakens. For graduates who want stability with meaningful operational impact, healthcare administration and health informatics can be strong options.

Government and public administration also tend to offer greater protection from sudden market swings. Agencies need professionals in information systems management, procurement, budget support, policy operations, public-facing digital services, and infrastructure technology. These roles may require patience with formal hiring processes, but they often provide predictable benefits and stronger job protection.

Cybersecurity and data analytics can be stable because organizations must protect systems, manage risk, and meet compliance obligations. However, private technology employers can still be volatile, particularly during funding changes, mergers, or market corrections. Graduates should distinguish between the stability of a skill area and the stability of a specific employer.

Financial services offers mixed recession resistance. Compliance, risk management, fraud prevention, and regulatory technology may remain important during downturns, while some revenue-driven or market-sensitive roles may be more exposed to hiring freezes or layoffs. FINRA certifications or other credentials may also affect entry and advancement.

Industry data shows that across all sectors, nearly 30% of roles related to applied business & technology maintained or increased hiring during recessionary times. Graduates who prioritize stability should look for employers with recurring revenue, essential services, strong public funding, compliance requirements, or long-term technology modernization plans. For some students, an accessible associate degree pathway can also support entry into stable business and technology support roles before pursuing further credentials.

What Role Does the Private Sector Play in Shaping Career Paths for Applied Business & Technology Degree Holders?

The private sector gives applied business & technology graduates the broadest range of career environments, from highly structured Fortune 500 companies to fast-moving startups. It often shapes careers through performance-based advancement, exposure to competitive markets, variable compensation, and rapid changes in tools, systems, and customer expectations.

Large employers such as JPMorgan Chase and General Electric may offer formal training, rotational programs, established promotion paths, and strong internal mobility. These companies can be a good fit for graduates who want mentorship, recognizable employer brands, and structured development. Startups and smaller firms may offer broader responsibilities earlier, faster learning, and quicker advancement for high performers, but they may also bring less stability, fewer formal supports, and more ambiguity.

  • Finance: Firms such as Goldman Sachs and Morgan Stanley hire graduates for risk management, operations analytics, fintech implementation, compliance systems, and business process improvement.
  • Technology: Microsoft and Google recruit for roles connected to data analytics, IT consulting, product operations, project coordination, and digital transformation. Remote and hybrid options may be more common here than in many traditional industries.
  • Healthcare: Johnson & Johnson and UnitedHealth Group use applied business & technology talent in health informatics, supply chain digitalization, data reporting, operations support, and compliance-focused roles.
  • Manufacturing and supply chain: Companies such as 3M and Caterpillar need professionals who can optimize logistics, integrate technology into production, analyze workflows, and support quality and procurement systems.

Private employers also differ sharply in culture. Some measure performance through detailed metrics, deadlines, client outcomes, and revenue impact. Others emphasize innovation, cross-functional teamwork, or operational excellence. Graduates should review not only salary but also manager quality, promotion criteria, training budgets, turnover, and whether the role builds transferable skills.

One graduate described the decision this way: “Moving between large corporations and startups forced me to define what I wanted. Big companies gave me stability and formal programs. Smaller firms gave me hands-on experience and faster responsibility. The private sector did more than provide jobs; it showed me where my business and technology skills could create visible results.”

How Do Public Sector and Government Agencies Compare to Private Employers for Applied Business & Technology Graduates?

Public sector and government jobs usually offer more stability, clearer pay structures, and stronger benefits than many private employers, while private companies often provide faster advancement, higher earning upside, and more flexible career movement. The better choice depends on whether a graduate values predictable security or accelerated growth.

  • Career structure: Government roles commonly follow civil service systems, including federal GS grades or state and local pay scales. Promotions may depend on tenure, performance, exams, formal qualifications, and available openings. Private employers tend to offer more flexible career paths, including lateral moves, project-based advancement, and faster movement into leadership when companies grow.
  • Compensation model: Public agency salaries are typically stable but capped by budget rules and standardized pay grades. Private companies may offer higher starting pay, bonuses, profit-sharing, commissions, or equity. Data from the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics often show median wages for business and technology jobs in private industries exceeding those in government, though this can vary by location and employer size.
  • Advancement opportunities: Government advancement is often slower but predictable. Private employers may reward innovation, technical skill, and leadership faster, but the trade-off can be greater exposure to layoffs, reorganizations, or market pressure.
  • Key employers: Major government agencies hiring Applied Business & Technology graduates include the Departments of Defense, Treasury, and Homeland Security. State-level IT offices, business management departments, and local government agencies also hire professionals for technology infrastructure, procurement, analytics, and administrative systems.
  • Pension and benefits: Public sector jobs frequently feature defined-benefit retirement plans, predictable health benefits, paid leave, and access to federal student loan forgiveness programs. Private employers more commonly offer defined-contribution plans, though some may provide stronger bonus or equity opportunities.
  • Job security: Government positions are generally less vulnerable to sudden layoffs than private sector roles. This stability can be especially valuable during recessions or industry disruptions.

The public sector can frustrate graduates who want fast promotions, flexible job titles, or large compensation jumps. It can be a strong match for those who value mission-driven work, public impact, benefits, and long-term security.

In 2023, federal data revealed a 4% rise in technology-related job openings within government agencies, reflecting growing digital transformation efforts and expanding career pathways for Applied Business & Technology graduates in public service.

Which Industries Offer the Clearest Leadership and Advancement Pathways for Applied Business & Technology Professionals?

The clearest leadership pathways are found in industries that define promotion criteria, invest in management development, and connect business results to measurable performance. For applied business & technology professionals, technology, financial services, healthcare administration, and manufacturing or supply chain often provide the most visible routes from entry-level roles to management, director, and executive positions within a decade or so.

  • Technology sector: Fast-growing technology employers often need people who can move from analyst, coordinator, or systems roles into product management, project leadership, operations management, or strategy. Leadership development programs, mentorship, and technical certifications can accelerate that transition. An MBA focused on technology management or data analytics may strengthen advancement prospects.
  • Financial services: Finance has established progression paths from analyst, compliance, operations, or risk roles into management and senior leadership. Performance metrics, regulatory expertise, and professional credentials often matter. Finance-focused MBAs and credentials like the CFA can improve executive role prospects.
  • Healthcare administration: Hospitals, insurers, health systems, and digital health firms need leaders who understand operations, patient data, compliance, budgeting, and technology implementation. Master's degrees in healthcare administration or an MBA focused on healthcare can speed entry into higher-level management roles.
  • Manufacturing and supply chain: These industries reward professionals who can improve quality, cost, logistics, production systems, and operational efficiency. Advancement may move from coordinator or analyst to supervisor, plant operations leader, logistics manager, director, or executive. Lean management credentials and specialized master's degrees in supply chain or operations can help.

Graduates should look for three signs of a strong advancement environment:

  • Transparent criteria: The employer explains what skills, metrics, certifications, and experience are required for promotion.
  • Merit-based evaluation: Advancement depends on measurable results and leadership ability, not only tenure.
  • Development investment: The organization funds training, mentoring, certification, rotational assignments, or leadership programs.

Long-Term Potential: Entry-level title matters less than whether the industry creates room to grow. Finance and healthcare may offer slower early movement than startups in some cases, but they can provide substantial executive pay scales and organizational influence over a ten-year horizon.

Workforce analyses reveal applied business & technology professionals in technology and financial services are nearly 30% more likely to reach senior leadership within 12 years than peers in other sectors, reflecting the value of structured advancement systems in those fields.

What Emerging and Technology-Driven Industries Are Creating New Demand for Applied Business & Technology Skills?

Emerging industries are creating demand for graduates who can connect innovation with business execution. Applied business & technology professionals are useful in these fields because they can support implementation, compliance, analytics, operations, vendor coordination, customer adoption, and process design—not just technical development.

  • Artificial Intelligence: AI demand extends beyond engineering roles. Employers need professionals who can evaluate business use cases, coordinate AI projects, analyze data, document workflows, manage risk, and support ethical compliance. Useful skills include data analytics, process automation, AI ethics, stakeholder communication, and strategic planning. AI certifications or machine learning coursework can improve readiness.
  • Clean Energy: Solar, wind, energy storage, grid modernization, and sustainability technology need business-minded professionals who can manage projects, track performance, navigate regulations, and optimize supply chains. Important competencies include sustainability metrics, project finance, compliance management, and vendor coordination. Certifications in environmental management or energy systems may improve competitiveness.
  • Biotechnology: Biotechnology combines science, data, regulation, and commercialization. Graduates may contribute to quality assurance, regulatory affairs, product development support, market analysis, data management, and operational planning. A basic understanding of bioprocess engineering concepts can be helpful even for non-laboratory roles.
  • Advanced Manufacturing: Robotics, industrial IoT, additive manufacturing, and digital supply chains are changing production environments. Employers value systems integration, lean manufacturing, analytics, cybersecurity fundamentals, and the ability to translate technical improvements into cost, quality, and productivity gains.
  • Digital Health: Telemedicine, health informatics, patient platforms, and remote monitoring tools create roles focused on implementation, privacy, workflow design, compliance, and customer experience. Helpful skills include health IT knowledge, regulatory awareness, data privacy, and change management.

These industries can offer strong upside, but they also carry risk. Some emerging markets grow unevenly, depend on funding cycles, or face regulatory uncertainty. Graduates should assess employer stability, market maturity, training support, and whether the skills they gain will transfer if the industry slows. Those seeking a faster credential route may consider an accelerated online business degree to build management and applied technology skills more efficiently.

How Do Nonprofit and Mission-Driven Organizations Compare as Career Options for Applied Business & Technology Graduates?

Nonprofit and mission-driven organizations can be strong career options for applied business & technology graduates who want their work to support social, educational, environmental, healthcare, or community goals. These organizations may not match private-sector salaries in many cases, but they can offer meaningful work, broad responsibility, strong benefits, and valuable cross-functional experience.

  • Compensation and benefits: Salaries often reflect nonprofit budget constraints, but benefits may include health insurance, retirement plans, paid time off, flexible schedules, and mission-oriented workplace cultures. Graduates should compare total compensation rather than base salary alone.
  • Advancement opportunities: Nonprofits may have flatter structures, which can limit formal promotion steps. At the same time, employees often take on broad responsibilities earlier, gaining experience in operations, technology systems, grants management, reporting, donor platforms, program analytics, and leadership support.
  • Financial incentives: Public Service Loan Forgiveness (PSLF) and other debt relief programs may help qualifying employees manage student loan obligations. This can partly offset salary differences for graduates who qualify and remain in eligible roles.
  • Mission alignment: For many professionals, purpose is a major part of job satisfaction. Working on education access, public health, environmental protection, community development, or social services can make the trade-off worthwhile.
  • Workplace culture: Mission-driven environments often emphasize collaboration, adaptability, and values-based decision-making. The best organizations pair that culture with realistic workloads and strong leadership; the weaker ones may rely too heavily on employee commitment without enough resources.
  • Transferable skill development: Nonprofit professionals often gain experience with budgeting, systems implementation, data reporting, stakeholder communication, process improvement, and project management—skills that can transfer to government, healthcare, education, and private employers.

Graduates considering nonprofit work should ask direct questions about funding stability, turnover, role scope, technology resources, training budgets, and promotion history. A mission is important, but sustainable work conditions matter too.

Some professionals also use continuing education to broaden the technical or analytical skills they can bring to mission-driven settings; for example, a flexible online physics degree may be relevant for certain research, education, or science-focused nonprofit roles.

Which Industries Support the Most Remote and Flexible Work Arrangements for Applied Business & Technology Degree Holders?

Technology, finance, and professional services are among the strongest industries for remote and hybrid roles for applied business & technology degree holders. These sectors rely heavily on cloud systems, digital communication, analytics platforms, and project management tools, making many business-technology functions less dependent on a single physical location.

  • Technology: Remote-friendly roles may include data analytics, IT project coordination, systems support, product operations, implementation, cybersecurity support, and digital transformation work. Many technology employers have built infrastructure for distributed teams.
  • Finance: Hybrid arrangements are common in financial planning, compliance, risk management, reporting, and operations roles, especially where secure systems allow employees to work outside the office part of the week.
  • Professional services: Consulting, marketing, business process outsourcing, and advisory firms often support location flexibility because client communication, reporting, analysis, and project coordination can be handled virtually.
  • Industries with fewer remote options: Manufacturing and healthcare may require more on-site work because production systems, equipment, facilities, and patient-facing operations often need physical presence. However, some analytics, scheduling, compliance, procurement, and administrative technology roles may still offer hybrid schedules.

Remote work can expand the job market significantly. Graduates may be able to live outside high-cost metro areas while applying to employers in larger markets. It can also improve work-life balance, reduce commuting costs, and make career options more accessible for people with caregiving responsibilities or geographic constraints.

Still, flexibility varies by employer, manager, and job function. Before accepting an offer, ask about mandatory office days, whether remote policies are written or informal, how performance is measured, what equipment is provided, and whether remote employees are promoted at the same rate as office-based peers.

Over 58% of business and technology roles now include at least partial remote work, a 20% rise in just two years, highlighting a major shift in workplace expectations for this career field.

How Do Industry-Specific Licensing and Certification Requirements Affect Applied Business & Technology Career Entry?

Licensing and certification requirements can affect how quickly applied business & technology graduates enter a field, how much they must spend after graduation, and how competitive they are for promotions. Some industries require formal credentials for specific roles, while others treat certifications as optional but valuable proof of skill.

  • Finance: Roles tied to securities, investment products, compliance, or analysis may require credentials such as CFA or FINRA licenses. These can involve exams, fees, employer sponsorship in some cases, and continuing education.
  • Healthcare technology: Health informatics and health information roles may value or require credentials from organizations such as AHIMA. Requirements can include rigorous exams, renewal rules, and ongoing professional development.
  • Information security: Cybersecurity roles often prefer certifications such as CISSP or CompTIA Security+. Some credentials require prior experience, while others are more accessible to early-career candidates.
  • Operations, logistics, and general business technology: These fields often have more direct entry routes based on degree completion, internships, technical familiarity, and work experience. Certifications such as Six Sigma or PMP can still improve credibility and promotion prospects.

Credentials can help in two main ways. First, they validate current skills in a language employers recognize. Second, they can shorten the path to higher-responsibility roles by showing commitment to a specialty. However, graduates should avoid collecting certifications without a target. A credential is most valuable when it matches a specific job posting, industry standard, or promotion requirement.

Before choosing an industry, check job descriptions, licensing boards, professional associations, and employer requirements. Rules can change, and some credentials require experience before eligibility. According to recent reports, nearly 70% of hiring managers in technology-driven sectors now prioritize applicants holding credentials beyond academic degrees, making certification strategy an important part of career planning.

What Graduates Say About the Industries That Offer the Best Career Paths for Applied Business & Technology Degree Graduates

  • : "“My applied business & technology degree helped me compare industries more realistically. Tech and finance stood out because compensation often reflects the pressure and skill involved. I also value stability, and the stronger companies in these fields gave me confidence that there would be room to grow. The advancement opportunities keep me motivated.” — Augustus"
  • : "“Healthcare technology surprised me in the best way. The work is technical, but the culture is collaborative because the mission matters. You are improving systems that affect patients and care teams. For me, the combination of stability, purpose, and long-term career security made this industry a strong fit after earning an applied business & technology degree.” — Antonio"
  • : "“Manufacturing and logistics gave me the structure I wanted. The promotion paths were easier to understand than in some other fields, and the work connected directly to measurable results. Compensation varies by employer, but the stability and clear progression made these industries a strong foundation for long-term growth.” — Julian"

Other Things You Should Know About Applied Business & Technology Degrees

What industries offer the best work-life balance and job satisfaction for Applied business & technology graduates?

Industries such as technology services, healthcare administration, and education technology tend to offer the best work-life balance for applied business & technology graduates. These sectors often provide flexible work arrangements-including remote options-and emphasize employee well-being. Job satisfaction is also higher in fields that align with personal values, such as sustainable business practices or nonprofit technology management.

How does geographic location influence industry opportunities for Applied business & technology degree holders?

Geographic location significantly shapes industry opportunities for applied business & technology degree holders. Metropolitan areas and tech hubs generally offer more diverse roles with higher salaries and advancement potential-especially in IT consulting, software development, and data analytics. Conversely, rural or less populated regions may present fewer openings but can offer strong opportunities in sectors like healthcare administration and manufacturing technology support.

Which industries invest the most in professional development and continuing education for Applied business & technology employees?

The technology and financial services industries consistently invest heavily in professional development for applied business & technology employees. These sectors allocate substantial resources to training programs, certifications, and leadership development aimed at keeping skills current amid rapid innovation. Healthcare administration is also notable for supporting continuing education, partly because of evolving regulatory and compliance requirements.

How should a Applied business & technology graduate evaluate industry fit based on their personal values and career goals?

Graduates should assess industries not only by salary and job availability but also by how well those sectors align with their long-term goals and ethical priorities. For instance, someone interested in social impact may prefer roles in education technology or nonprofit management. Evaluating company culture, mission, and advancement pathways within target industries is essential to ensure a sustainable and fulfilling career.

References

Related Articles
2026 What Careers Can You Pursue With an Applied Business & Technology Degree? Salary Potential, Job Outlook, and Next Steps thumbnail
2026 What Job Postings Reveal About Applied Business & Technology Careers: Skills, Degrees, and Experience Employers Want thumbnail
2026 Applied Business & Technology Degree Careers That Do Not Require Graduate School thumbnail
2026 Which Applied Business & Technology Degree Careers Have the Lowest Unemployment Risk? thumbnail
2026 Which Applied Business & Technology Degree Careers Offer the Best Return Without Graduate School? thumbnail
2026 Is an Applied Business & Technology Degree Better Than Experience Alone? Salary, Hiring, and Career Growth Compared thumbnail